Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Mele, Isabella; McGill, Rona A R; Thompson, J; Fennell, James; Fitzer, Susan C (2023): Seawater carbonate chemistry and biomineralization pathways and shell material properties of Magallana gigas and Mytilus spp [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.960043

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX Citation

Abstract:
Molluscs are among the organisms affected by ocean acidification (OA), relying on carbon for shell biomineralization. Metabolic and environmental sourcing are two pathways potentially affected by OA, but the circumstances and patterns by which they are altered are poorly understood. From previous studies, mollusc shells grown under OA appear smaller in size, brittle and thinner, suggesting an important alteration in carbon sequestration. However, supplementary feeding experiments have shown promising results in offsetting the negative consequences of OA on shell growth. Our study compared carbon uptake by δ13C tracing and deposition into mantle tissue and shell layers in Magallana gigas and Mytilus species, two economically valuable and common species. After subjecting the species to 7.7 pH, +2 °C seawater, and enhanced feeding, both species maintain shell growth and metabolic pathways under OA without benefitting from extra feeding, thus, showing effective acclimation to rapid and short-term environmental change. Mytilus spp. increases metabolic carbon into the calcite and environmental sourcing of carbon into the shell aragonite in low pH and high temperature conditions. Low pH affects M. gigas mantle nitrogen isotopes maintaining growth. Calcite biomineralization pathway differs between the two species and suggests species-specific response to OA.
Keyword(s):
Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Bottles or small containers/Aquaria (<20 L); Growth/Morphology; Laboratory experiment; Laboratory strains; Magallana gigas; Mytilus spp.; Not applicable; Other; Other studied parameter or process; Single species; Temperature
Supplement to:
Mele, Isabella; McGill, Rona A R; Thompson, J; Fennell, James; Fitzer, Susan C (2023): Ocean acidification, warming and feeding impacts on biomineralization pathways and shell material properties of Magallana gigas and Mytilus spp. Marine Environmental Research, 186, 105925, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marenvres.2023.105925
Documentation:
Gattuso, Jean-Pierre; Epitalon, Jean-Marie; Lavigne, Héloïse; Orr, James; Gentili, Bernard; Hagens, Mathilde; Hofmann, Andreas; Mueller, Jens-Daniel; Proye, Aurélien; Rae, James; Soetaert, Karline (2022): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 3.3.1. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/seacarb/index.html
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Gattuso et al, 2022) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation by seacarb is 2023-06-26.
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
Type of studyStudy typeFitzer, Susan C
SpeciesSpeciesFitzer, Susan C
TreatmentTreatFitzer, Susan C
MassMasskgFitzer, Susan Cshell
Shell lengthShell lmmFitzer, Susan C
Shell widthShell wmmFitzer, Susan C
Shell thicknessShell thickmmFitzer, Susan C
Shell thickness indexSTIFitzer, Susan C
Diagonal lengthDiag lmmFitzer, Susan C1
10 Diagonal lengthDiag lmmFitzer, Susan C2
11 Vickers HardnessVHHVFitzer, Susan C
12 Vickers hardnessVHMPaFitzer, Susan C
13 Treatment: pHT:pHFitzer, Susan C
14 Treatment: temperatureT:temp°CFitzer, Susan C
15 TreatmentTreatFitzer, Susan CFeeding
16 IdentificationIDFitzer, Susan CTank
17 δ13Cδ13C‰ PDBFitzer, Susan Cmantle
18 δ15Nδ15NFitzer, Susan Cmantle
19 δ13C, calciteδ13C cal‰ PDBFitzer, Susan C
20 δ18O, calciteδ18O cal‰ PDBFitzer, Susan C
21 δ13C, aragoniteδ13C arg‰ PDBFitzer, Susan C
22 δ18O, aragoniteδ18O arg‰ PDBFitzer, Susan C
23 Cell densityCells#/mlFitzer, Susan CFeeding
24 Temperature, waterTemp°CFitzer, Susan C
25 Temperature, water, standard deviationTemp std dev±Fitzer, Susan C
26 pHpHFitzer, Susan CNBS scale
27 pH, standard deviationpH std dev±Fitzer, Susan CNBS scale
28 SalinitySalFitzer, Susan C
29 Salinity, standard deviationSal std dev±Fitzer, Susan C
30 δ13C, dissolved inorganic carbonδ13C DIC‰ PDBFitzer, Susan Cin DIC
31 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmFitzer, Susan C
32 ReplicateReplFitzer, Susan C
33 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgFitzer, Susan C
34 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
35 pHpHYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)total scale
36 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
37 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
38 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
39 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
40 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
41 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
42 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
43 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
Status:
Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)
Size:
5968 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


Study type

Species

Treat

Mass [kg]
(shell)

Shell l [mm]

Shell w [mm]

Shell thick [mm]

STI

Diag l [mm]
(1)
10 
Diag l [mm]
(2)
11 
VH [HV]
12 
VH [MPa]
13 
T:pH
14 
T:temp [°C]
15 
Treat
(Feeding)
16 
ID
(Tank)
17 
δ13C [‰ PDB]
(mantle)
18 
δ15N []
(mantle)
19 
δ13C cal [‰ PDB]
20 
δ18O cal [‰ PDB]
21 
δ13C arg [‰ PDB]
22 
δ18O arg [‰ PDB]
23 
Cells [#/ml]
(Feeding)
24 
Temp [°C]
25 
Temp std dev [±]
26 
pH
(NBS scale)
27 
pH std dev [±]
(NBS scale)
28 
Sal
29 
Sal std dev [±]
30 
δ13C DIC [‰ PDB]
(in DIC)
31 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
32 
Repl
33 
DIC [µmol/kg]
34 
CSC flag
35 
pH
(total scale)
36 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
37 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
38 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
39 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
40 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
41 
AT [µmol/kg]
42 
Omega Arg
43 
Omega Cal
laboratoryMagallana gigas10.05969.056.036.40.81502273.1840000073.1840103.848134301018.40230608.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas10.053105.051.817.90.58633077.4390000077.468092.71476557909.22125588.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas10.04772.356.619.20.69242472.0920000072.1160106.982386201049.13881808.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas10.06181.349.527.00.84714472.2350000073.9720104.091662901020.79050608.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas20.05990.258.721.30.66685075.9570000075.957096.40407181945.40099087.714control800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas20.04481.042.216.50.76321066.6200000067.9370122.890975301205.14878307.714control800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas20.05786.243.024.40.85146275.4670000075.493097.62638641957.38780237.714control800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas30.05287.547.125.70.70511976.9177777877.848092.88739778910.91419948.114Extra Feeding1600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas30.04580.249.527.70.62973382.4570000081.182083.08903367814.82507208.114Extra Feeding1600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas30.06178.555.330.20.78512471.7030000071.6810108.215532901061.23185608.114Extra Feeding1600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas40.05684.251.126.00.73848775.3980000076.028097.02811461951.52076017.714Extra Feeding1600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas40.04589.241.523.20.67550276.3070000076.004095.90255013940.48274327.714Extra Feeding1600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas50.03468.043.417.50.68021777.0520000077.046093.69080538918.79293668.116control800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas50.05382.652.325.20.70362378.6350000078.744089.82508179880.88313838.116control800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas60.04069.956.919.80.60468778.8400000079.330088.92971789872.10261797.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas60.05777.059.029.80.71297176.4530000076.459095.14979111933.10069907.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas60.05796.749.124.70.68274872.3280000072.5370106.014419201039.64630407.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas60.06081.650.029.40.80703173.5030000073.7830102.558015801005.75056607.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas70.06088.040.225.60.91075670.0170000070.0280113.437269101112.43959508.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas70.05172.546.623.90.85510271.0540000071.3280109.744409501076.22501308.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas70.03364.636.821.50.76303780.9270000083.219082.58763896809.90806968.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas70.04991.247.122.50.65527873.7400000080.923093.20857675914.06388928.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas80.05885.638.727.50.90858168.6080000068.5590118.247441001159.61126707.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas80.04967.062.325.20.69280267.5980000068.3110120.449914101181.21015007.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas80.06090.948.721.50.78935575.0800000075.259098.43471251965.31477347.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas80.04978.440.524.60.83967878.1420000078.138091.09282506893.31545297.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.10.01655.827.720.00.53429070.8410000066.3430118.345349101160.57141808.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.10.01453.027.118.50.51249973.2250000072.8290104.295905101022.79343808.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.10.01457.325.318.90.49253968.8920000068.1950118.388538101160.99495708.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.10.01757.826.719.70.56430271.9609090972.2745106.942232801048.74504708.114control800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.20.01556.426.419.10.51961070.8850000071.7530109.354479301072.40110407.714control800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.20.01555.827.419.80.50623572.1370000076.4280100.88356310989.32979417.714control800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.20.01657.225.118.40.57218863.8260000066.6236130.799252101282.70248607.714control800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.20.01555.128.719.00.50352168.5809090969.1327117.312483301150.44246407.714control800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.30.01454.125.518.30.52488368.4578571473.1750111.031179301088.84391408.114Extra Feeding1600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.30.01856.927.520.20.59021575.1608333380.955891.40952014896.42117078.114Extra Feeding1600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.30.01657.028.819.20.51627772.7490000081.398093.92695050921.10872918.114Extra Feeding1600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.30.01352.027.317.70.48916973.0015384677.355498.49367352965.89298348.114Extra Feeding1600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.40.01048.323.817.00.45064975.1718181880.250992.19895914904.16292277.714Extra Feeding1600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.40.01759.826.020.80.54354276.6020000077.163094.09829874922.78908137.714Extra Feeding1600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.40.01556.126.019.00.52859148.6510000048.4950235.744869202311.86742207.714Extra Feeding1600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.40.01251.225.916.90.48246747.0740000049.9720236.441197502318.69606907.714Extra Feeding1600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.50.01856.826.919.80.60400582.4790000093.648072.00938320706.17081788.116control800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.50.01555.824.320.70.53611172.4050000074.1290103.627324401016.23690108.116control800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.50.01554.527.319.10.52588973.8072727373.8809101.999877301000.27709708.116control800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.50.01755.927.819.90.56628974.1700000074.4140100.77389750988.25434198.116control800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.60.01552.526.419.50.55419572.1225000073.7067104.629281901026.06274707.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.60.01454.226.819.80.49350769.1750000076.9580104.478768301024.58671307.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.60.01657.427.418.10.54038771.6318181878.381899.06261252971.47236917.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.60.01756.527.319.90.56699768.6854545572.8282111.190230801090.40367707.716control800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.70.02061.028.221.30.59062569.4780000071.1680112.486114301103.11195308.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.70.01353.523.917.40.52326564.5781818281.7755105.322694901032.86280608.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.70.01859.426.020.90.57830471.1660000071.3740109.501077301073.83874008.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.70.01858.527.519.20.58403966.3820000068.8360121.720863801193.67390908.116Extra Feeding1600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.80.01351.924.819.20.50842874.7918181874.882799.31055259973.90383067.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.80.01453.525.918.30.52531673.7870000076.105099.04622801971.31169197.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.80.01556.226.018.40.53345369.7950000073.5780108.307540601062.13414307.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.80.01860.829.120.00.53376471.3500000075.2164103.639298201016.35432407.716Extra Feeding1600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control1-21.077.98800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control1-21.578.61800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control2-21.378.02800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control2-21.398.05800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control3-21.817.60800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control3-21.027.74800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control4-21.887.67800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control4-20.698.29800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding5-21.198.391600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding5-22.237.071600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding6-21.038.441600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding6-20.667.891600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding7-21.417.521600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding7-21.857.051600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding8-20.767.701600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding8-21.237.931600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control9-21.538.30800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control9-20.807.85800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control10-21.057.45800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control10-20.668.08800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control11-21.688.16800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control11-21.017.97800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control12-21.787.50800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control12-20.867.64800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding13-20.467.941600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding13-21.677.931600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding14-21.397.601600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding14-20.597.941600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding15-21.467.551600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding15-21.477.741600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding16-20.757.971600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding16-20.817.541600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control1-19.637.08800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control1-20.306.98800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control2-20.096.84800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control2-20.397.32800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control3-20.227.49800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control3-20.246.96800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control4-19.446.93800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control4-18.897.53800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding5-20.277.931600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding5-20.506.051600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding6-19.517.751600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding6-20.277.371600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding7-20.356.611600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding7-19.787.781600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding8-20.854.471600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding8-20.337.301600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control9-19.607.18800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control9-19.417.75800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control10-19.728.01800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control10-19.538.37800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control11-20.107.60800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control11-20.226.39800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control12-19.604.83800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control12-20.518.00800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding13-19.987.491600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding13-19.886.801600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding14-20.478.211600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding14-19.597.431600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding15-18.967.211600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding15-19.567.851600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding16-19.457.461600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding16-19.967.471600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.74767.69770.521395.0442.221511.500.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control1-1.381.09800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control1-0.840.42800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control2-0.960.82800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas18.114control2-1.720.14800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.081106.351110.552947.21100.713179.801.562.49
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control30.32800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control3-0.720.15800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control4-0.55-0.01800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas27.714control4-0.370.84800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.00666.03668.551157.4528.551239.800.440.69
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding5-1.010.631600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding5-1.560.511600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding6-1.080.531600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas38.114Extra Feeding61600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.181281.023724.63140.094038.802.173.47
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding7-0.550.661600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding71600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding8-18.870.341600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas47.714Extra Feeding8-0.66-1.721600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.35859.46862.701391.2734.381486.900.520.81
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control9-0.820.14800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control9-0.840.02800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control10-1.231.05800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas58.116control10-4.881.29800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.061061.963278.56170.503672.402.584.02
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control11-2.400.13800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control11-1.340.16800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control12-0.790.37800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas67.716control12-0.056.35800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.65685.69688.221218.4635.901321.500.540.85
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding13-0.930.941600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.291084.292371.1286.942583.601.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding131.890.511600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.201084.192371.1286.952583.611.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding14-0.940.561600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.201084.192371.1286.952583.611.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas78.116Extra Feeding14-1.120.591600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.201084.192371.1286.952583.611.322.05
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding15-1.200.301600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding15-0.720.411600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding160.061600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00
laboratoryMagallana gigas87.716Extra Feeding16-0.380.811600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control1-1.420.85-2.130.06800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.071106.231110.432947.21100.723179.821.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control1-1.450.87800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.071106.231110.432947.21100.723179.821.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control2-2.090.95-2.450.43800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.071106.231110.432947.21100.723179.821.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.18.114control2-1.391.00-1.960.20800000011.450.867.910.0828.424.07-1.495061-43096277.7948.071106.231110.432947.21100.723179.821.562.49
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control3-0.76-2.480.38800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.01666.11668.631157.4528.541239.790.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control3-2.290.19-4.080.44800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.01666.11668.631157.4528.541239.790.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control4-0.76-0.35-3.140.30800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.01666.11668.631157.4528.541239.790.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.27.714control4-0.22-0.82-2.540.17800000011.700.847.710.0732.781.42-5.498265-81214277.6028.01666.11668.631157.4528.541239.790.440.69
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding5-1.451.42-2.320.591600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.291281.143724.64140.084038.782.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding5-1.940.081600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.291281.143724.64140.084038.782.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding6-1.92-0.06-2.590.061600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.291281.143724.64140.084038.782.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.38.114Extra Feeding6-2.400.18-2.51-0.151600000011.550.877.950.1528.424.07-1.766619-123920277.8355.281276.291281.143724.64140.084038.782.173.47
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding7-0.700.23-2.720.101600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.36859.69862.941391.2734.371486.870.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding7-1.091.23-3.19-0.771600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.36859.69862.941391.2734.371486.870.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding8-13.76-100.96-3.080.151600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.36859.69862.941391.2734.371486.870.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.47.714Extra Feeding8-3.250.561600000011.800.857.670.1336.103.84-6.5695113-161461277.5635.36859.69862.941391.2734.371486.870.520.81
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control9-1.34800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.121062.023278.57170.493672.392.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control90.56-1.680.28800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.121062.023278.57170.493672.392.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control10-2.700.13-3.130.43800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.121062.023278.57170.493672.392.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.58.116control10-1.940.662.33-2.67800000013.651.037.960.0936.583.84-1.5752117-203490277.8540.941058.121062.023278.57170.493672.392.584.02
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control11800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.64685.64688.171218.4535.901321.510.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control11-2.440.62-2.680.48800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.64685.64688.171218.4535.901321.510.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control12-0.670.39-3.760.74800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.64685.64688.171218.4535.901321.510.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.67.716control12-1.750.55-4.490.79800000013.601.037.720.9336.103.84-2.6780021-241281277.6126.64685.64688.171218.4535.901321.510.540.85
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding13-1.101.21-2.56-0.511600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.201084.192371.1286.952583.611.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding13-2.58-3.800.771600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.201084.192371.1286.952583.611.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding14-3.961.42-1.530.331600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.201084.192371.1286.952583.611.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.78.116Extra Feeding140.51-2.500.201600000013.551.077.810.1136.583.84-3.7758428-322500277.7041.931080.201084.192371.1286.952583.611.322.05
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding15-1.320.35-4.55-0.141600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding15-4.190.28-3.650.901600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding16-1.850.83-3.810.201600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00
laboratoryMytilus spp.87.716Extra Feeding16-0.68-2.18-0.561600000013.701.027.730.1336.103.84-5.9782133-361467277.6229.75767.95770.781395.0442.211511.470.641.00