Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Paula, José Ricardo; Baptista, Miguel; Carvalho, Francisco; Repolho, Tiago; Bshary, Redouan; Rosa, Rui (2019): Seawater carbonate chemistry and fish cognitive performance [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.914654

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX Citation

Abstract:
Ocean acidification is one of the many consequences of climate change. Various studies suggest that marine organisms' behaviour will be impaired under high CO2. Here, we show that the cognitive performance of the cleaner wrasse, Labroides dimidiatus, has not suffered from the increase of CO2 from pre-industrial levels to today, and that the standing variation in CO2 tolerance offers potential for adaptation to at least 750 µatm. We acclimated cleaners over 30 days to five levels of pCO2, from pre-industrial to high future CO2 scenarios, before testing them in an ecologically relevant task—the ability to learn to prioritize an ephemeral food source over a permanent one. Fish learning abilities remained stable from pre-industrial to present-day pCO2. While performance was reduced under mid (750 µatm) and high CO2 (980 µatm) scenarios, under the former 36% of cleaners still solved the task. The presence of tolerant individuals reveals potential for adaptation, as long as selection pressure on cognitive performance is strong. However, the apparent absence of high CO2 tolerant fish, and potentially synergistic effects between various climate change stressors, renders the probability of further adaptation unlikely.
Keyword(s):
Animalia; Behaviour; Bottles or small containers/Aquaria (<20 L); Chordata; Coast and continental shelf; Indian Ocean; Laboratory experiment; Labroides dimidiatus; Nekton; Pelagos; Single species; Tropical
Supplement to:
Paula, José Ricardo; Baptista, Miguel; Carvalho, Francisco; Repolho, Tiago; Bshary, Redouan; Rosa, Rui (2019): The past, present and future of cleaner fish cognitive performance as a function of CO2 levels. Biology Letters, 15(12), 20190618, https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2019.0618
Original version:
Paula, José Ricardo; Baptista, Miguel; Carvalho, Francisco; Repolho, Tiago; Bshary, Redouan; Rosa, Rui (2019): Data from: The past, present and future of cleaner fish cognitive performance as a function of CO2 levels. figshare, https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.9101993
Further details:
Gattuso, Jean-Pierre; Epitalon, Jean-Marie; Lavigne, Héloïse; Orr, James C; Gentili, Bernard; Hagens, Mathilde; Hofmann, Andreas; Mueller, Jens-Daniel; Proye, Aurélien; Rae, James; Soetaert, Karline (2019): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 3.2.12. https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=seacarb
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Gattuso et al, 2019) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation by seacarb is 2020-04-02.
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
TypeTypePaula, José Ricardostudy
SpeciesSpeciesPaula, José Ricardo
Registration number of speciesReg spec noPaula, José Ricardo
Uniform resource locator/link to referenceURL refPaula, José RicardoWoRMS Aphia ID
IdentificationIDPaula, José RicardoIndividual
Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmPaula, José Ricardo
CategoryCatPaula, José Ricardosolved
Numbern#Paula, José Ricardotrials
IdentificationIDPaula, José Ricardosystem
10 CategoryCatPaula, José Ricardoplate
11 SalinitySalPaula, José Ricardo
12 Temperature, waterTemp°CPaula, José Ricardo
13 Temperature, water, standard deviationTemp std dev±Paula, José Ricardo
14 pHpHPaula, José Ricardototal scale
15 pH, standard deviationpH std dev±Paula, José Ricardototal scale
16 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgPaula, José Ricardo
17 Alkalinity, total, standard deviationAT std dev±Paula, José Ricardo
18 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgPaula, José RicardoCalculated using CO2SYS
19 Carbon, inorganic, dissolved, standard deviationDIC std dev±Paula, José RicardoCalculated using CO2SYS
20 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmPaula, José RicardoCalculated using CO2SYS
21 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide, standard deviationpCO2 std dev±Paula, José RicardoCalculated using CO2SYS
22 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgPaula, José RicardoCalculated using CO2SYS
23 Aragonite saturation state, standard deviationOmega Arg std dev±Paula, José RicardoCalculated using CO2SYS
24 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
25 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
26 Carbon dioxide, standard deviationCO2 std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
27 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
28 Fugacity of carbon dioxide in seawater, standard deviationfCO2 std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
29 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
30 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide, standard deviationpCO2 std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
31 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
32 Bicarbonate ion, standard deviation[HCO3]- std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
33 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
34 Carbonate ion, standard deviation[CO3]2- std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
35 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
36 Carbon, inorganic, dissolved, standard deviationDIC std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
37 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
38 Aragonite saturation state, standard deviationOmega Arg std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
39 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
40 Calcite saturation state, standard deviationOmega Cal std dev±Yang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Orr et al. (2018)
Status:
Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)
Size:
2360 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


Type
(study)

Species

Reg spec no

URL ref
(WoRMS Aphia ID)

ID
(Individual)

pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]

Cat
(solved)

n [#]
(trials)

ID
(system)
10 
Cat
(plate)
11 
Sal
12 
Temp [°C]
13 
Temp std dev [±]
14 
pH
(total scale)
15 
pH std dev [±]
(total scale)
16 
AT [µmol/kg]
17 
AT std dev [±]
18 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
19 
DIC std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
20 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
21 
pCO2 std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
22 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
23 
Omega Arg std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
24 
CSC flag
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
25 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
26 
CO2 std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
27 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
28 
fCO2 std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
29 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
30 
pCO2 std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
31 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
32 
[HCO3]- std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
33 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
34 
[CO3]2- std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
35 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
36 
DIC std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
37 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
38 
Omega Arg std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
39 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
40 
Omega Cal std dev [±]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org1315.971201green3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org2276.501102green3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org3276.501503green3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org4276.501604green3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org5315.9701005blue3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org6276.501206green3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org7315.971207green3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org8315.9701008blue3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org9750.0001009blue3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org10750.00010010green3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org11315.971901blue3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org12276.501602blue3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org13276.5001003blue3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org14276.501304green3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org15315.971605green3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org16276.501606green3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org17315.971407green3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org18315.971208green3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org19750.001509green3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org20750.0014010blue3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org21315.971801green3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org22276.501802blue3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org23276.501103blue3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org24276.5001004green3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org25315.9701005blue3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org26276.5001006blue3525.960.078.200.01245924201925263.510.04.960.0587.480.28269.9710.14270.8210.171717.6526.58304.979.732030.1023.704.860.277.350.41
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org27315.971607blue3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org28315.971608blue3525.870.108.150.01244027204125305.211.14.510.1088.630.32310.8111.60311.8011.631763.3727.76278.129.262050.1326.084.430.256.710.38
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org30750.00010010blue3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org31750.00010011green3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org32980.0012012green3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org33404.21010013green3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org34980.0012014green3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org35404.21010015green3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org36750.00010016blue3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org37980.00010017blue3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org38404.2117018green3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org39980.00010019green3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org40404.2118020blue3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org41750.0017011green3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org42980.00010012blue3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org43404.2118013blue3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org44980.00010014blue3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org45404.2114015green3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org46750.00010016blue3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org47980.00010017blue3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org48404.21010018blue3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org49980.00010019green3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org50404.2118020blue3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org51750.0019011blue3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org52980.00010012blue3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org53404.2117013green3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org54980.0012014green3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org55404.2118015green3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org56750.00010016blue3525.610.097.840.01246125224930734.231.72.600.05820.860.71746.0525.40748.4325.492076.1924.91158.865.932255.9124.632.530.153.830.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org57980.00010017blue3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org58404.2117018green3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org59980.00010019green3525.630.047.770.02250228231637933.541.52.380.14825.511.44912.8151.68915.7151.842161.8629.56140.907.252328.2628.642.240.153.400.23
laboratoryLabroides dimidiatus (fish)219014marinespecies.org60404.2118020blue3525.650.058.060.01248517214619405.513.13.910.06811.490.40411.4414.44412.7414.481899.7621.74241.608.092152.8518.113.850.225.820.33