Citation:

PANGAEA.913183

Name: Seawater carbonate chemistry and calcification, survival, concentrations of Symbiodiniaceae, chlorophyll a and protein of Caribbean corals
Published: 2019
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Keywords: Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Biomass/Abundance/Elemental composition; Calcification/Dissolution; Cnidaria; Coast and continental shelf; Field experiment; Growth/Morphology; Laboratory strains; Mortality/Survival; North Atlantic; Porites astreoides; Porites porites; Siderastrea siderea; Single species; Tropical

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS Citation BibTeX Citation Text Citation Facebook TwitterShow Map Google Earth

Abstract:

Coral calcification is expected to decline as atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration increases. We assessed the potential of Porites astreoides, Siderastrea siderea and Porites porites to survive and calcify under acidified conditions in a 2-year field transplant experiment around low pH, low aragonite saturation (Omega arag) submarine springs. Slow-growing S. siderea had the highest post-transplantation survival and showed increases in concentrations of Symbiodiniaceae, chlorophyll a and protein at the low Omega arag site. Nubbins of P. astreoides had 20% lower survival and higher chlorophyll a concentration at the low Omega arag site. Only 33% of P. porites nubbins survived at low Omega arag and their linear extension and calcification rates were reduced. The density of skeletons deposited after transplantation at the low Omega arag spring was 15–30% lower for all species. These results suggest that corals with slow calcification rates and high Symbiodiniaceae, chlorophyll a and protein concentrations may be less susceptible to ocean acidification, albeit with reduced skeletal density. We postulate that corals in the springs are responding to greater energy demands for overcoming larger differences in carbonate chemistry between the calcifying medium and the external environment. The differential mortality, growth rates and physiological changes may impact future coral species assemblages and the reef framework robustness.

Keyword(s):

Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Biomass/Abundance/Elemental composition; Calcification/Dissolution; Cnidaria; Coast and continental shelf; Field experiment; Growth/Morphology; Laboratory strains; Mortality/Survival; North Atlantic; Porites astreoides; Porites porites; Siderastrea siderea; Single species; Tropical

Supplement to:

Martinez, Ana; Crook, Elizabeth Derse; Barshis, Daniel J; Potts, Donald C; Rebolledo-Vieyra, Mario; Hernandez, Laura; Paytan, Adina (2019): Species-specific calcification response of Caribbean corals after 2-year transplantation to a low aragonite saturation submarine spring. Proceedings of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 286(1905), 20190572, https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2019.0572

Original version:

Martinez, Ana; Crook, Elizabeth Derse; Barshis, Daniel J; Potts, Donald C; Rebolledo-Vieyra, Mario; Hernandez, Laura; Paytan, Adina (2019): Data from: Species-specific calcification response of Caribbean corals after two-year transplantation to low aragonite saturation submarine springs. Dryad, https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.3pm80bp

Further details:

Gattuso, Jean-Pierre; Epitalon, Jean-Marie; Lavigne, Héloïse; Orr, James C; Gentili, Bernard; Hagens, Mathilde; Hofmann, Andreas; Mueller, Jens-Daniel; Proye, Aurélien; Rae, James; Soetaert, Karline (2019): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 3.2.12. https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=seacarb

Project(s):

Ocean Acidification International Coordination Centre (OA-ICC)

Coverage:

Latitude: 20.879230 * Longitude: -86.860920

Date/Time Start: 2010-08-28T00:00:00 * Date/Time End: 2011-10-19T00:00:00

Event(s):

Ojo_Laja * Latitude: 20.879230 * Longitude: -86.860920 * Date/Time Start: 2010-08-28T00:00:00 * Date/Time End: 2011-10-19T00:00:00 * Method/Device: Experiment (EXP)

Comment:

In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Gattuso et al, 2019) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation by seacarb is 2020-03-06.

Parameter(s):

#	Name	Short Name	Unit	Principal Investigator	Method/Device	Comment
1	Type	Type		Paytan, Adina		study
2	Species	Species		Paytan, Adina
3	Registration number of species	Reg spec no		Paytan, Adina
4	Uniform resource locator/link to reference	URL ref		Paytan, Adina		WoRMS Aphia ID
5	Identification	ID		Paytan, Adina
6	Site	Site		Paytan, Adina		origin
7	Site	Site		Paytan, Adina		transplant
8	Duration	Duration	month	Paytan, Adina		RTE
9	Proportion of survival	Survival		Paytan, Adina
10	Linear extension	Lin ext	µm	Paytan, Adina
11	Density	Density	g/cm³	Paytan, Adina
12	Volume	Vol	ml	Paytan, Adina		tissue
13	Area	Area	cm²	Paytan, Adina		tissue
14	Chlorophyll a	Chl a	µg/l	Paytan, Adina
15	Cell density	Cells	#/ml	Paytan, Adina		symbiod
16	Proteins	Protein	µg/l	Paytan, Adina
17	Number	n	#	Paytan, Adina
18	Alkalinity, total	AT	µmol/kg	Paytan, Adina
19	Alkalinity, total, standard error	AT std e	±	Paytan, Adina
20	Carbon, inorganic, dissolved	DIC	µmol/kg	Paytan, Adina
21	Carbon, inorganic, dissolved, standard error	DIC std e	±	Paytan, Adina
22	pH	pH		Paytan, Adina		NBS scale
23	pH, standard error	pH std e	±	Paytan, Adina		NBS scale
24	Aragonite saturation state	Omega Arg		Paytan, Adina
25	Aragonite saturation state, standard error	Omega Arg std e	±	Paytan, Adina
26	Temperature, water	Temp	°C	Paytan, Adina
27	Temperature, water, standard error	T std e	±	Paytan, Adina
28	Salinity	Sal		Paytan, Adina
29	Salinity, standard error	Sal std e	±	Paytan, Adina
30	Carbonate system computation flag	CSC flag		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
31	pH	pH		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)	total scale
32	Carbon dioxide	CO2	µmol/kg	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
33	Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	fCO2water_SST_wet	µatm	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
34	Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	pCO2water_SST_wet	µatm	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
35	Bicarbonate ion	[HCO3]-	µmol/kg	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
36	Carbonate ion	[CO3]2-	µmol/kg	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
37	Aragonite saturation state	Omega Arg		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
38	Calcite saturation state	Omega Cal		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)

License:

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC-BY-4.0)

Status:

Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)

Size:

4227 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:

1 Type (study)	2 Species	3 Reg spec no	4 URL ref (WoRMS Aphia ID)	5 ID	6 Site (origin)	7 Site (transplant)	8 Duration [month] (RTE)	9 Survival	10 Lin ext [µm]	11 Density [g/cm³]	12 Vol [ml] (tissue)	13 Area [cm²] (tissue)	14 Chl a [µg/l]	15 Cells [#/ml] (symbiod)	16 Protein [µg/l]	17 n [#]	18 AT [µmol/kg]	19 AT std e [±]	20 DIC [µmol/kg]	21 DIC std e [±]	22 pH (NBS scale)	23 pH std e [±] (NBS scale)	24 Omega Arg	25 Omega Arg std e [±]	26 Temp [°C]	27 T std e [±]	28 Sal	29 Sal std e [±]	30 CSC flag	31 pH (total scale)	32 CO2 [µmol/kg]	33 fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]	34 pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]	35 [HCO3]- [µmol/kg]	36 [CO3]2- [µmol/kg]	37 Omega Arg	38 Omega Cal
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	3	Reef	Control	24	0	4700	1.654	7.0	7.121	3891	1500000	212000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	4	Reef	Ojo	24	0	4800	1.155	16.0	6.152	30925	7550000	676000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	9	Reef	Control	24	0	7400							15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	10	Reef	Ojo	24	0	7000		27.0			2450000	168000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	12	Reef	Control	24	0	4900	1.741	4.0		2808	1233333	139000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	13	Reef	Ojo	24	0	9300	1.573	15.0	7.879	39667	10500000	790000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	15	Reef	Control	24	0	3900	1.688	5.0	4.840	5481	1683333	203000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	18	Reef	Control	24	0	7500	1.618	6.0	1.045	2357	516667	129000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	19	Reef	Ojo	24	0	7100	1.448	17.0	10.136	24664	4783333	524000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	21	Reef	Control	24	0	5500	1.702	12.0	6.736	5122	1350000	312000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	22	Reef	Ojo	24	0	9200	1.485	35.0	8.322	47022	15600000	479000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	24	Reef	Control	24	0	5200	1.590	9.0	8.190	17745	7100000	1330000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	25	Reef	Ojo	24	0	2900		5.0	1.301	2860	850000	57000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	27	Reef	Control	24	0	8000	1.637	5.0	21.876	10190	3500000	292000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	30	Reef	Control	24	0	8900	1.631	10.0	14.677	19196	5210000	815000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	31	Reef	Ojo	24	0	4700		14.0		7482	1250000	864000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	33	Reef	Control	24	0			10.0		10549	1866667	377000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	36	Reef	Control	24	0	34300	1.648	20.0	5.695	17704	5016667	762000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	39	Reef	Control	24	0	28100	1.734	22.0	4.347	7038	1050000	518000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	45	Reef	Control	24	0	39100	1.722	5.0		6497			15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	48	Reef	Control	24	0	18700	1.339	11.0	4.325	10303	3966667	527000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	51	Reef	Control	24	0	26100	1.653	7.0	5.849	2309	983333	202000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	54	Reef	Control	24	0	15900	1.720				4133333		15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	57	Reef	Control	24	0	17700	1.715	40.0	20.412	49568	7300000	1039000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	40	Reef	Ojo	24	0	11500	1.438	5.0	3.496	5825	1875000	140000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	49	Reef	Ojo	24	0	11400	1.287	10.0		20909	2733333	433000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	58	Reef	Ojo	24	0	10200	1.205	5.0	0.334	18902	2000000	143000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	261	Ojo	Control	24	0	7500	1.616	14.0	7.850	25516	4633333	818000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	264	Ojo	Control	24	0	8000		25.0		25294	6000000		15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	267	Ojo	Control	24	0	8500	1.496	62.0	37.458		4300000		15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	270	Ojo	Control	24	0	9100	1.692	23.0	12.063	18451	5200000	689000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	276	Ojo	Control	24	0	8400	1.579	25.0	6.769	28222	4600000	458000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	279	Ojo	Control	24	0	8600	1.554	7.5	6.148	9360	2450000	166000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	282	Ojo	Control	24	0	6300	1.610	17.0	17.830	39048	8500000	861000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	288	Ojo	Control	24	0	6100	1.524	26.0	10.227	23945	7583333	547000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	268	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	14100	1.066	7.0	2.944	27971	3066667	261000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	271	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	13600	1.287	23.0	7.301	45189	7437500	395000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	277	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	9500	1.027	30.0	8.140	131907	20833333	1209000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	283	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	17600	1.123	6.0	5.992	64206	5933333	467000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	289	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	17000	1.139	10.0	3.652	42216	4300000	203000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	291	Control	Control	24	0	11200		50.0		1680	130000		15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	292	Control	Ojo	24	0	6100							17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	294	Control	Control	24	0	11800	1.605	7.0	6.500	8833	1683333	1036000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	295	Control	Ojo	24	0	7700	1.078	35.0	10.905	122311	14833333	1680000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	297	Control	Control	24	0	6300	1.541	38.0	12.597			618000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	298	Control	Ojo	24	0	17000		20.0	5.570	80946	9666667	682000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	300	Control	Control	24	0	6600	1.546	18.0	4.573	12824	2816667	287000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	313	Control	Control	24	0	5900	1.624	15.0	7.503	22519	3566667	354000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	314	Control	Ojo	24	0	7800	1.067	25.0	5.743	115145	10633333	1264000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	316	Control	Control	24	0	6300		26.0		3081	2312500	202000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	317	Control	Ojo	24	0	10800	1.074	7.0	7.369	27729	4666667	300000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	319	Control	Control	24	0	6700	1.472	16.0	10.452	15013	4662500	1078000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	322	Control	Control	24	0	9300	1.698	15.0	5.768	9192	2216667	216000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	325	Control	Control	24	0	9400	1.735	36.0	9.565	53856	9266667	604000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	326	Control	Ojo	24	0	5100	1.211	17.0	10.677	75106	9225000	1041000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	328	Control	Control	24	0	9900	1.536	38.0	34.258	45038	8766667	1405000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	329	Control	Ojo	24	0		1.298	6.0	8.428	24328	3616667	352000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	331	Ojo	Control	24	0	2500	1.428	6.0	2.664	3904	1150000	155000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	332	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	5700	1.243	13.0	6.275	54355	9000000	690000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	334	Ojo	Control	24	0	3800		6.0	5.363	7027	1666667	149000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	335	Ojo	Ojo	24	0			15.0		36709	7900000	688000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	337	Ojo	Control	24	0	2700	1.539	10.0	6.809	4493	1225000	785000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	338	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	3800	1.377	10.0	5.554	22779	4833333	697000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	340	Ojo	Control	24	0	1900		4.0	2.321	861	180000	26000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	341	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	2500	1.318	9.0	3.502	27585	3200000	350000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	343	Ojo	Control	24	0	3100	1.479	4.0	7.644	1678	550000	133000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	344	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	3400	1.226	6.0	7.174	38155	5216667	436000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	346	Ojo	Control	24	0	4600	1.677	10.0	5.380	8290	4600000	320000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	347	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	4300	1.362	7.0	3.246	18237	3450000	208000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	349	Control	Control	24	0	4400	1.665	6.0	1.877		1800000	1145000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	350	Control	Ojo	24	0	5300	1.344	10.0	11.346	64586	13000000	2129000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	362	Control	Control	24	0	1700		16.0	6.130	10187	3220000	449000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	363	Control	Ojo	24	0	1400		5.0	6.611	13949	1183333	266000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	365	Control	Control	24	0	2400		4.0	0.309	1088	533333	449000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	366	Control	Ojo	24	0	7400	1.431	20.0	6.610	83939	12166667	713000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	368	Control	Control	24	0	2100		7.0	0.444	7261	2800000		15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	371	Control	Control	24	0	5200	1.772	10.0	10.152	4621	3216667	448000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	372	Control	Ojo	24	0	3900	1.562	16.0	2.739	11579	3100000	395000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	374	Control	Control	24	0	2000		3.0	1.808	2044	550000	45000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	375	Control	Ojo	24	0	4500	1.254	6.0	6.417	31212	7366667	314000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	377	Control	Control	24	0	4300	1.700	24.0	8.654	16115	5083333	772000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	378	Control	Ojo	24	0	7500	1.521	12.0	2.868	13881	3283333	505000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	380	Control	Control	24	0	2500	1.574	8.0	6.630	4084	2366667	221000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	381	Control	Ojo	24	0								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	383	Control	Control	24	0	3800							15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	384	Control	Ojo	24	0	3000		17.5	1.924	20225	1833333	316000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	386	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	1800		17.0	4.776	61587	8866667	561000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	389	Ojo	Control	24	0	3000	1.532	4.0	1.417	1631	716667	89000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	390	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	4800	1.404	4.0	2.403	10801	1850000	185000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	392	Ojo	Control	24	0								15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	393	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	4800							17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	395	Ojo	Control	24	0	5100	1.424	4.0	1.805	1430	316667	63000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	398	Ojo	Control	24	0	1600		3.0	1.433	1996	333333	49000	15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	399	Ojo	Ojo	24	0	2300		28.0	6.256		10200000	1368000	17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	6	Reef	Ojo	10	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	7	Reef	Control	10	1								15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	16	Reef	Ojo	2	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	28	Reef	Ojo	1	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	42	Reef	Control	2	1								15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	60	Reef	Control	10	1								15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	37	Reef	Ojo	22	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	43	Reef	Ojo	12	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	46	Reef	Ojo	10	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	52	Reef	Ojo	24	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	55	Reef	Ojo	22	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	61	Reef	Ojo	12	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	273	Ojo	Control	1	1								15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	285	Ojo	Control	1	1								15	2365	32	2019	12	8.17	0.07	3.53	0.43	26.9	0.3	35.6	0.1	15	8.07	10.04	371.96	373.12	1763.31	245.64	3.92	5.90
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	262	Ojo	Ojo	1	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	265	Ojo	Ojo	22	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	274	Ojo	Ojo	24	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	280	Ojo	Ojo	24	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	286	Ojo	Ojo	12	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	311	Control	Ojo	22	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	320	Control	Ojo	22	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites astreoides (coral)	288889	marinespecies.org	323	Control	Ojo	12	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Siderastrea siderea (coral)	207516	marinespecies.org	369	Control	Ojo	22	1								17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15
field	Porites porites (coral)	207238	marinespecies.org	34	Reef	Ojo										17	2759	104	2621	93	7.70	0.14	2.10	0.35	27.1	0.2	33.2	0.5	15	7.67	36.17	1329.59	1333.74	2456.62	128.21	2.08	3.15