Al-Janabi, Balsam; Wahl, Martin; Kruse, Inken (2019): Experiment on sensitivities of the macroalgal Fucus vesiculosus germlings to ocean warming, ocean acidification, nutrient enrichment and hypoxia: survival and growth [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.900089, Supplement to: Al-Janabi, Balsam; Wahl, Martin; Karsten, Ulf; Graiff, Angelika; Kruse, Inken (2019): Sensitivities to global change drivers may correlate positively or negatively in a foundational marine macroalga. Scientific Reports, 9(1), https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-51099-8
Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.
Abstract:
Paired (male and female) Fucus vesiculosus from Kiel Bight were made to release gametes which after fertilization were allowed to settle onto sand-stone cubes. The offspring of one parental pair represented a "sibling group". Replicates of each sibling groups were distributed among the various treatments in the Kiel Outdoor Benthocosms (KOB, Wahl et al. 2015). As fitness proxies we measured (i) growth and (ii) survival of the germlings. The independent treatments were ocean warming OW (delta of 5°C over ambient conditions), ocean acidification OA (delta of 700 µatm CO2 over ambient condition), combined OAW, nutrient addition (double than ambient) or hypoxia associated with a provoked upwelling of deep water). Sensitivity was quantified for each replicate of a given sibling group as Log Response Ratio of the metric (survival, growth) under a given treatment relative to the same metric under ambient conditions. The experiment ran intermittently from spring 2013 to autumn 2014.
Coverage:
Latitude: 54.330000 * Longitude: 10.150000
Date/Time Start: 2013-01-01T00:00:00 * Date/Time End: 2014-01-01T00:00:00
Comment:
Kiel Outdoor Benthocosms
Treatments:
OA: delta of 700 µatm CO2 over ambient condition
OW: delta of 5°C over ambient conditions
OAW: combination of OA and OW
Nutrients: double than ambient
Hypoxia
Parameter(s):
# | Name | Short Name | Unit | Principal Investigator | Method/Device | Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Species | Species | Wahl, Martin | |||
2 | Treatment | Treat | Wahl, Martin | |||
3 | Group | Group | Wahl, Martin | Sibling | ||
4 | Period | Period | Wahl, Martin | |||
5 | DATE/TIME | Date/Time | Wahl, Martin | Geocode | ||
6 | Response ratio, logarithm | log response | Wahl, Martin | Survival | ||
7 | Standard error | Std e | ± | Wahl, Martin | Response ratio, logarithm; Survival | |
8 | Response ratio, logarithm | log response | Wahl, Martin | Growth | ||
9 | Standard error | Std e | ± | Wahl, Martin | Response ratio, logarithm; Growth |
License:
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC-BY-4.0)
Size:
596 data points
Data
1 Species | 2 Treat | 3 Group (Sibling) | 4 Period | 5 Date/Time | 6 log response (Survival) | 7 Std e [±] (Response ratio, logarithm; Su...) | 8 log response (Growth) | 9 Std e [±] (Response ratio, logarithm; Gr...) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 1 | Spring | 2013 | 0.001732937 | 0.055297959 | -0.279186548 | 0.108478442 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 2 | Spring | 2013 | -0.217119870 | 0.335780089 | -0.680894517 | |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 3 | Spring | 2013 | 0.180178205 | 0.139514024 | -0.424558611 | 0.093670788 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 4 | Spring | 2013 | 0.228500585 | 0.121784292 | -0.303732350 | 0.064036163 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 5 | Spring | 2013 | -0.100461106 | 0.072939979 | -0.520000441 | 0.121961605 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 6 | Spring | 2013 | 0.374522081 | 0.159104889 | -0.039301401 | 0.112786852 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 7 | Spring | 2013 | 0.024237655 | 0.334381906 | -0.160642317 | 0.092418771 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 8 | Spring | 2013 | 0.108692080 | 0.174164336 | -0.162286746 | 0.161762866 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 1 | Spring | 2013 | -0.004390306 | 0.044918908 | -0.131670448 | 0.039722332 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 2 | Spring | 2013 | -0.370867921 | 0.400633004 | -0.668669465 | |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 3 | Spring | 2013 | 0.085367090 | 0.132676836 | -0.195178752 | 0.060669075 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 4 | Spring | 2013 | 0.206814064 | 0.125681498 | -0.001478474 | 0.069923808 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 5 | Spring | 2013 | -0.371134277 | 0.268102802 | -0.135456740 | 0.103931290 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 6 | Spring | 2013 | 0.337815335 | 0.168041171 | 0.175310638 | 0.072290360 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 7 | Spring | 2013 | -0.065021569 | 0.316415035 | 0.024374383 | 0.048236689 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 8 | Spring | 2013 | 0.088128540 | 0.204186807 | 0.142745807 | 0.164468443 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 1 | Summer | 2013 | 0.229329292 | 0.190172910 | 0.111569754 | 0.082836966 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 2 | Summer | 2013 | ||||
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 3 | Summer | 2013 | 0.041639220 | 0.273814254 | 0.242903804 | 0.069414826 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 4 | Summer | 2013 | -0.019470818 | 0.335424165 | 0.074003505 | 0.040992597 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 5 | Summer | 2013 | 0.312499519 | 0.136404166 | 1.219544607 | 0.252057571 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 6 | Summer | 2013 | -0.422258891 | 0.109840745 | -0.742300183 | 0.193553176 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 7 | Summer | 2013 | 0.273086961 | 0.309638831 | 0.164261623 | 0.125850319 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OA | 8 | Summer | 2013 | 0.141491766 | 0.273094278 | -0.691045270 | 0.268168961 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 1 | Summer | 2013 | 0.118107113 | 0.184351468 | 1.043634588 | 0.246736568 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 2 | Summer | 2013 | ||||
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 3 | Summer | 2013 | -0.285370554 | 0.254571857 | 1.394192830 | 0.314052646 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 4 | Summer | 2013 | -0.036594696 | 0.314080085 | 1.288787526 | 0.324526877 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 5 | Summer | 2013 | -0.444355981 | 0.216682558 | 1.440390464 | 0.286077225 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 6 | Summer | 2013 | -0.605585731 | 0.137935218 | -0.142472629 | 0.283332413 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 7 | Summer | 2013 | -0.167286031 | 0.256507871 | 0.925457795 | 0.248859822 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OW | 8 | Summer | 2013 | -0.760988740 | 0.138296814 | -0.325530179 | 0.317707867 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 1 | Summer | 2014 | -0.448781166 | 0.188664500 | -0.401880546 | 0.087486326 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 2 | Summer | 2014 | -0.549439500 | 0.285506395 | -0.318713402 | 0.058882247 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 3 | Summer | 2014 | -0.536445454 | 0.234015665 | -0.218466268 | 0.046995064 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 4 | Summer | 2014 | -0.070898147 | 0.036649674 | -0.197999297 | 0.029113638 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 5 | Summer | 2014 | -0.174455611 | 0.186602250 | -0.457410715 | 0.061890877 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 6 | Summer | 2014 | 0.161489155 | 0.137719891 | -0.294887361 | 0.068978265 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 7 | Summer | 2014 | -0.855906107 | 0.262116034 | -0.267243459 | 0.038070783 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 8 | Summer | 2014 | -0.268579958 | 0.218080015 | -0.463045717 | 0.078883979 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 9 | Summer | 2014 | -0.123055501 | 0.111997873 | -0.315793304 | 0.072160679 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 10 | Summer | 2014 | 0.037788561 | 0.020823123 | -0.152197835 | 0.071140687 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 11 | Summer | 2014 | -0.354108789 | 0.250745347 | -0.481116695 | 0.051058214 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 12 | Summer | 2014 | -0.832963523 | 0.255885757 | -0.373142214 | 0.084937412 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 13 | Summer | 2014 | -0.289593854 | 0.230312364 | -0.227340078 | 0.073314203 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 14 | Summer | 2014 | -0.400881883 | 0.333978608 | -0.329062204 | 0.098765821 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 15 | Summer | 2014 | -0.566360006 | 0.184098001 | -0.654145361 | 0.053960506 |
Fucus vesiculosus | OAW | 16 | Summer | 2014 | -0.140161762 | 0.154681455 | -0.353524483 | 0.035876560 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 1 | Summer | 2014 | 0.152874023 | 0.152473563 | -0.252834163 | 0.050057489 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 2 | Summer | 2014 | 0.064101784 | 0.120173929 | -0.028119487 | 0.061514098 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 3 | Summer | 2014 | 0.185037623 | 0.037540591 | 0.185276848 | 0.055897392 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 4 | Summer | 2014 | 0.015585422 | 0.011513286 | 0.136857520 | 0.026887395 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 5 | Summer | 2014 | -0.005314686 | 0.013463333 | -0.154881395 | 0.053093643 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 6 | Summer | 2014 | 0.180990957 | 0.136937470 | 0.115016552 | 0.066299317 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 7 | Summer | 2014 | 0.056218415 | 0.042004276 | 0.128021445 | 0.035113769 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 8 | Summer | 2014 | 0.057192769 | 0.025180979 | -0.036652074 | 0.064208426 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 9 | Summer | 2014 | -0.024500328 | 0.119279554 | -0.043570300 | 0.073526016 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 10 | Summer | 2014 | -0.138957644 | 0.061364068 | 0.125237040 | 0.074852457 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 11 | Summer | 2014 | -0.028305337 | 0.003020000 | -0.127436774 | 0.054944918 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 12 | Summer | 2014 | -0.012992282 | 0.007890000 | 0.050401008 | 0.025853771 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 13 | Summer | 2014 | -0.036099461 | 0.069148297 | 0.172622382 | 0.088530021 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 14 | Summer | 2014 | 0.039940759 | 0.012153934 | 0.144413760 | 0.106796139 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 15 | Summer | 2014 | -0.034275442 | 0.028966214 | -0.090826541 | 0.039632939 |
Fucus vesiculosus | Nutrients | 16 | Summer | 2014 | 0.061483601 | 0.025919026 | 0.028144761 | |
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 1 | Summer | 2014 | 0.126692394 | 0.153650329 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 2 | Summer | 2014 | 0.252454909 | 0.102361751 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 3 | Summer | 2014 | 0.184231552 | 0.038565204 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 4 | Summer | 2014 | -0.359990457 | 0.113862391 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 5 | Summer | 2014 | -0.249580604 | 0.096653037 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 6 | Summer | 2014 | -0.148684220 | |||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 7 | Summer | 2014 | 0.029704504 | 0.040586829 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 8 | Summer | 2014 | -0.107078067 | 0.066439099 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 9 | Summer | 2014 | -0.177273193 | 0.198010784 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 10 | Summer | 2014 | -0.322905565 | 0.057013955 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 11 | Summer | 2014 | -0.085631718 | 0.032100000 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 12 | Summer | 2014 | -0.038850673 | 0.012900000 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 13 | Summer | 2014 | -0.001760000 | 0.032039610 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 14 | Summer | 2014 | 0.010219944 | 0.022206749 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 15 | Summer | 2014 | -0.070126953 | 0.031559508 | ||
Fucus vesiculosus | Hypoxia | 16 | Summer | 2014 | -0.108794749 | 0.143428662 |