Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Forsgren, Elisabet; Dupont, Sam; Jutfelt, Fredrik; Amundsen, Trond (2013): Elevated CO2 affects embryonic development and larval phototaxis in a temperate marine fish [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.839190, Supplement to: Forsgren, E et al. (2013): Elevated CO2 affects embryonic development and larval phototaxis in a temperate marine fish. Ecology and Evolution, 3(11), 3637-3646, https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.709

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX CitationShow MapGoogle Earth

Abstract:
As an effect of anthropogenic CO2 emissions, the chemistry of the world's oceans is changing. Understanding how this will affect marine organisms and ecosystems are critical in predicting the impacts of this ongoing ocean acidification. Work on coral reef fishes has revealed dramatic effects of elevated oceanic CO2 on sensory responses and behavior. Such effects may be widespread but have almost exclusively been tested on tropical reef fishes. Here we test the effects elevated CO2 has on the reproduction and early life history stages of a temperate coastal goby with paternal care by allowing goby pairs to reproduce naturally in an aquarium with either elevated (ca 1400 µatm) CO2 or control seawater (ca 370 µatm CO2). Elevated CO2 did not affect the occurrence of spawning nor clutch size, but increased embryonic abnormalities and egg loss. Moreover, we found that elevated CO2 significantly affected the phototactic response of newly hatched larvae. Phototaxis is a vision-related fundamental behavior of many marine fishes, but has never before been tested in the context of ocean acidification. Our findings suggest that ocean acidification affects embryonic development and sensory responses in temperate fishes, with potentially important implications for fish recruitment.
Keyword(s):
Animalia; Behaviour; Chordata; Coast and continental shelf; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Development; Gobiusculus flavescens; Laboratory experiment; Nekton; North Atlantic; Pelagos; Reproduction; Single species; Temperate
Further details:
Lavigne, Héloïse; Epitalon, Jean-Marie; Gattuso, Jean-Pierre (2014): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 3.0. https://cran.r-project.org/package=seacarb
Coverage:
Latitude: 58.250000 * Longitude: 11.450000
Date/Time Start: 2010-07-20T00:00:00 * Date/Time End: 2010-08-24T00:00:00
Event(s):
Kristineberg * Latitude: 58.250000 * Longitude: 11.450000 * Date/Time Start: 2010-07-20T00:00:00 * Date/Time End: 2010-08-24T00:00:00 * Method/Device: Experiment (EXP)
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne et al, 2014) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation is 2014-11-21.
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
SpeciesSpeciesForsgren, Elisabet
TreatmentTreatForsgren, Elisabet
IdentificationIDForsgren, Elisabetaquarium
Incubation durationInc durdaysForsgren, Elisabet
EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabettotal
EmbryosEmbryos%Forsgren, Elisabetnormal
EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabetall abnormal and unfertilised
EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabetall abnormal incl upside down
EmbryosEmbryos%Forsgren, Elisabetall abnormal incl upside down
10 EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabetunfertilised
11 EmbryosEmbryos%Forsgren, Elisabetunfertilised
12 EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabetdeformed w eyes, all
13 EmbryosEmbryos%Forsgren, Elisabetw eyes
14 EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabetdeveloped eyes
15 EmbryosEmbryos%Forsgren, Elisabetlarge eyes
16 EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabetother (stopped early
17 EmbryosEmbryos%Forsgren, Elisabetstopped in between
18 EmbryosEmbryos#Forsgren, Elisabetupside down (not abnormal)
19 EmbryosEmbryos%Forsgren, Elisabetupside down
20 Duration, number of daysDurationdaysForsgren, Elisabetdays past fertilisation, min
21 Duration, number of daysDurationdaysForsgren, Elisabetdays past fertilisation, max
22 Abnormality, cumulativeAbn cumForsgren, Elisabet
23 EggsEggs#Forsgren, Elisabetday 1-2
24 EggsEggs#Forsgren, Elisabetday 9
25 EggsEggs#Forsgren, Elisabetlost
26 PercentagePerc%Forsgren, Elisabetlost
27 Eggs survived to hatchingEggs survived hatch%Forsgren, Elisabetremaining at d9
28 Phototactic responsePhototactic resp%Forsgren, Elisabet
29 Swimming durationSwim dursForsgren, Elisabetmean batch 1-3
30 SalinitySalForsgren, Elisabet
31 Temperature, waterTemp°CForsgren, Elisabet
32 pHpHForsgren, ElisabetPotentiometrictotal scale
33 pH, standard errorpH std e±Forsgren, ElisabetPotentiometrictotal scale
34 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgForsgren, ElisabetPotentiometric titration
35 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmForsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
36 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air), standard errorpCO2water_SST_wet std e±Forsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
37 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgForsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
38 Bicarbonate ion, standard error[HCO3]- std e±Forsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
39 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgForsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
40 Carbonate ion, standard error[CO3]2- std e±Forsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
41 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalForsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
42 Calcite saturation state, standard errorOmega Cal std e±Forsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
43 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgForsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
44 Aragonite saturation state, standard errorOmega Arg std e±Forsgren, ElisabetCalculated using CO2SYS
45 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
46 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
47 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
48 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
49 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
50 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
51 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
52 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
53 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
Status:
Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)
Size:
5589 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


Species

Treat

ID
(aquarium)

Inc dur [days]

Embryos [#]
(total)

Embryos [%]
(normal)

Embryos [#]
(all abnormal and unfertilised)

Embryos [#]
(all abnormal incl upside down)

Embryos [%]
(all abnormal incl upside down)
10 
Embryos [#]
(unfertilised)
11 
Embryos [%]
(unfertilised)
12 
Embryos [#]
(deformed w eyes, all)
13 
Embryos [%]
(w eyes)
14 
Embryos [#]
(developed eyes)
15 
Embryos [%]
(large eyes)
16 
Embryos [#]
(other (stopped early)
17 
Embryos [%]
(stopped in between)
18 
Embryos [#]
(upside down (not abnormal))
19 
Embryos [%]
(upside down)
20 
Duration [days]
(days past fertilisation, min)
21 
Duration [days]
(days past fertilisation, max)
22 
Abn cum
23 
Eggs [#]
(day 1-2)
24 
Eggs [#]
(day 9)
25 
Eggs [#]
(lost)
26 
Perc [%]
(lost)
27 
Eggs survived hatch [%]
(remaining at d9)
28 
Phototactic resp [%]
29 
Swim dur [s]
(mean batch 1-3)
30 
Sal
31 
Temp [°C]
32 
pH
(total scale, Potentiometric)
33 
pH std e [±]
(total scale, Potentiometric)
34 
AT [µmol/kg]
(Potentiometric titration)
35 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
36 
pCO2water_SST_wet std e [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
37 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
38 
[HCO3]- std e [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
39 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
40 
[CO3]2- std e [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
41 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
42 
Omega Cal std e [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
43 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
44 
Omega Arg std e [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
45 
CSC flag
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
46 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
47 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
48 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
49 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
50 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
51 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
52 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
53 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO219299798.059602.0060.20301.0020.07210.7010.033214.97.610.0123001268382152460.31.51.470.040.940.02847.351243.571239.132151.7360.432259.510.941.47
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control29157097.046472.9950.32130.8300.00281.7810.063214.98.100.012300357818956165.22.54.010.062.560.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO239146598.423231.5710.07151.0200.0070.4800.003214.97.590.0123001315192157258.10.71.410.020.900.01849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control49140397.929302.1420.14110.7800.00161.1410.073214.98.090.012300373819076160.22.43.890.062.490.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO259161789.417017210.64241.48694.2730.19774.7620.123214.97.580.0123001365262161256.31.01.370.020.870.01850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control69160797.147472.9220.12191.1800.00261.6200.003214.98.100.012300363718995163.32.14.000.052.530.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO279129189.95013110.15110.85171.3200.00221.70816.273214.97.420.02230020121092201540.41.80.980.040.630.03875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control89159389.516716710.4800.00583.6430.191096.8400.003214.98.080.012300376419093159.21.33.870.032.470.02814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control99241399.7880.3300.0030.1210.0450.2100.003214.98.090.012300371719056160.82.73.910.062.500.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control109283997.756642.2520.07240.8530.11301.0680.283214.98.100.012300358618965164.82.04.010.052.560.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO211963199.0660.9500.0030.4810.1630.4800.003214.97.590.0123001324462157558.21.81.410.040.900.03849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO212998698.713131.3200.00101.0130.3030.3000.003214.97.590.0123001316412157458.41.61.420.040.910.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control139141599.112130.9210.0760.4230.2150.3510.073214.98.090.012300366819026162.42.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control149113897.825252.20100.8840.3510.09110.9700.003214.98.090.912300373719075160.22.23.890.052.480.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2159123297.232352.8440.32171.3870.57110.8930.243214.97.590.0123001319392157458.21.51.420.040.900.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control179235099.115200.8500.0050.2110.04100.4350.213214.98.090.012300365819016162.72.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2189114697.824252.1860.5240.3510.09141.2210.093214.97.600.0123001294382155459.21.51.440.040.920.02848.521274.411269.862154.9059.142262.560.921.44
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control199147499.113130.8800.0080.5430.2050.3400.003214.98.110.012300354718925166.12.24.040.052.580.03813.14345.19343.961888.76167.742069.642.604.07
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control219131699.011130.9910.0890.6820.1510.0820.153214.98.090.012300372719065160.52.23.900.052.490.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2229119298.122231.9370.5960.5020.1790.7610.083214.97.580.0123001375412162456.11.51.360.040.870.02850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control23985894.546475.48252.91111.2820.23101.1710.123214.98.090.012300369719045161.42.13.920.052.500.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control25976699.3550.6500.0030.3910.1320.2600.003214.98.100.012300360818977164.32.63.990.062.550.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2269149288.017217912.00644.2950.3440.271036.9070.473214.97.420.03230020631612201640.32.60.980.060.630.04875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control279103899.4660.5810.1030.2910.1020.1900.003214.98.080.012300378719115158.72.13.870.052.460.03814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2289146478.132032021.8640.2750.3410.0731121.2400.003214.97.580.0123001350562159557.42.11.400.050.890.03850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21010.203214.97.610.0123001268382152460.31.51.470.040.940.02847.351243.571239.132151.7360.432259.510.941.47
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2010.323214.98.100.012300357818956165.22.54.010.062.560.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO23010.073214.97.590.0123001315192157258.10.71.410.020.900.01849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control4010.143214.98.090.012300373819076160.22.43.890.062.490.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO25011.483214.97.580.0123001365262161256.31.01.370.020.870.01850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control6010.123214.98.100.012300363718995163.32.14.000.052.530.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO27010.853214.97.420.02230020121092201540.41.80.980.040.630.03875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control8010.003214.98.080.012300376419093159.21.33.870.032.470.02814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control9010.003214.98.090.012300371719056160.82.73.910.062.500.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control10010.073214.98.100.012300358618965164.82.04.010.052.560.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO211010.003214.97.590.0123001324462157558.21.81.410.040.900.03849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO212010.003214.97.590.0123001316412157458.41.61.420.040.910.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control13010.073214.98.090.012300366819026162.42.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control14010.883214.98.090.912300373719075160.22.23.890.052.480.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO215010.323214.97.590.0123001319392157458.21.51.420.040.900.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control17010.003214.98.090.012300365819016162.72.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO218010.523214.97.600.0123001294382155459.21.51.440.040.920.02848.521274.411269.862154.9059.142262.560.921.44
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control19010.003214.98.110.012300354718925166.12.24.040.052.580.03813.14345.19343.961888.76167.742069.642.604.07
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control21010.083214.98.090.012300372719065160.52.23.900.052.490.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO222010.593214.97.580.0123001375412162456.11.51.360.040.870.02850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control23012.913214.98.090.012300369719045161.42.13.920.052.500.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control25010.003214.98.100.012300360818977164.32.63.990.062.550.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO226014.293214.97.420.03230020631612201640.32.60.980.060.630.04875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control27010.103214.98.080.012300378719115158.72.13.870.052.460.03814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO228010.273214.97.580.0123001350562159557.42.11.400.050.890.03850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21230.903214.97.610.0123001268382152460.31.51.470.040.940.02847.351243.571239.132151.7360.432259.510.941.47
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2232.103214.98.100.012300357818956165.22.54.010.062.560.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO23230.553214.97.590.0123001315192157258.10.71.410.020.900.01849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control4231.283214.98.090.012300373819076160.22.43.890.062.490.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO25236.253214.97.580.0123001365262161256.31.01.370.020.870.01850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control6231.743214.98.100.012300363718995163.32.14.000.052.530.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO27232.563214.97.420.02230020121092201540.41.80.980.040.630.03875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control8236.843214.98.080.012300376419093159.21.33.870.032.470.02814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control9230.213214.98.090.012300371719056160.82.73.910.062.500.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control10231.133214.98.100.012300358618965164.82.04.010.052.560.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO211230.483214.97.590.0123001324462157558.21.81.410.040.900.03849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO212230.303214.97.590.0123001316412157458.41.61.420.040.910.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control13230.423214.98.090.012300366819026162.42.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control14231.853214.98.090.912300373719075160.22.23.890.052.480.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO215231.223214.97.590.0123001319392157458.21.51.420.040.900.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control17230.433214.98.090.012300365819016162.72.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO218231.753214.97.600.0123001294382155459.21.51.440.040.920.02848.521274.411269.862154.9059.142262.560.921.44
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control19230.343214.98.110.012300354718925166.12.24.040.052.580.03813.14345.19343.961888.76167.742069.642.604.07
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control21230.153214.98.090.012300372719065160.52.23.900.052.490.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO222231.343214.97.580.0123001375412162456.11.51.360.040.870.02850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control23234.083214.98.090.012300369719045161.42.13.920.052.500.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control25230.263214.98.100.012300360818977164.32.63.990.062.550.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2262311.193214.97.420.03230020631612201640.32.60.980.060.630.04875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control27230.293214.98.080.012300378719115158.72.13.870.052.460.03814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2282321.523214.97.580.0123001350562159557.42.11.400.050.890.03850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21451.843214.97.610.0123001268382152460.31.51.470.040.940.02847.351243.571239.132151.7360.432259.510.941.47
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2452.933214.98.100.012300357818956165.22.54.010.062.560.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO23451.573214.97.590.0123001315192157258.10.71.410.020.900.01849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control4452.073214.98.090.012300373819076160.22.43.890.062.490.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO254510.333214.97.580.0123001365262161256.31.01.370.020.870.01850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control6452.923214.98.100.012300363718995163.32.14.000.052.530.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO27453.873214.97.420.02230020121092201540.41.80.980.040.630.03875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control84510.303214.98.080.012300376419093159.21.33.870.032.470.02814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control9450.293214.98.090.012300371719056160.82.73.910.062.500.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control10451.873214.98.100.012300358618965164.82.04.010.052.560.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO211450.793214.97.590.0123001324462157558.21.81.410.040.900.03849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO212451.013214.97.590.0123001316412157458.41.61.420.040.910.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control13450.643214.98.090.012300366819026162.42.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control14452.113214.98.090.912300373719075160.22.23.890.052.480.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO215452.033214.97.590.0123001319392157458.21.51.420.040.900.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control17450.603214.98.090.012300365819016162.72.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO218452.013214.97.600.0123001294382155459.21.51.440.040.920.02848.521274.411269.862154.9059.142262.560.921.44
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control19450.683214.98.110.012300354718925166.12.24.040.052.580.03813.14345.19343.961888.76167.742069.642.604.07
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control21450.683214.98.090.012300372719065160.52.23.900.052.490.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO222451.683214.97.580.0123001375412162456.11.51.360.040.870.02850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control23455.133214.98.090.012300369719045161.42.13.920.052.500.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control25450.523214.98.100.012300360818977164.32.63.990.062.550.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2264511.263214.97.420.03230020631612201640.32.60.980.060.630.04875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control27450.483214.98.080.012300378719115158.72.13.870.052.460.03814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2284521.793214.97.580.0123001350562159557.42.11.400.050.890.03850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21681.903214.97.610.0123001268382152460.31.51.470.040.940.02847.351243.571239.132151.7360.432259.510.941.47
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2682.933214.98.100.012300357818956165.22.54.010.062.560.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO23681.573214.97.590.0123001315192157258.10.71.410.020.900.01849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control4682.073214.98.090.012300373819076160.22.43.890.062.490.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO256810.513214.97.580.0123001365262161256.31.01.370.020.870.01850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control6682.923214.98.100.012300363718995163.32.14.000.052.530.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO27683.873214.97.420.02230020121092201540.41.80.980.040.630.03875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control86810.483214.98.080.012300376419093159.21.33.870.032.470.02814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control9680.333214.98.090.012300371719056160.82.73.910.062.500.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control10681.973214.98.100.012300358618965164.82.04.010.052.560.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO211680.953214.97.590.0123001324462157558.21.81.410.040.900.03849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO212681.323214.97.590.0123001316412157458.41.61.420.040.910.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control13680.853214.98.090.012300366819026162.42.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control14682.203214.98.090.912300373719075160.22.23.890.052.480.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO215682.603214.97.590.0123001319392157458.21.51.420.040.900.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control17680.643214.98.090.012300365819016162.72.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO218682.093214.97.600.0123001294382155459.21.51.440.040.920.02848.521274.411269.862154.9059.142262.560.921.44
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control19680.883214.98.110.012300354718925166.12.24.040.052.580.03813.14345.19343.961888.76167.742069.642.604.07
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control21680.843214.98.090.012300372719065160.52.23.900.052.490.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO222681.853214.97.580.0123001375412162456.11.51.360.040.870.02850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control23685.363214.98.090.012300369719045161.42.13.920.052.500.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control25680.653214.98.100.012300360818977164.32.63.990.062.550.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2266811.533214.97.420.03230020631612201640.32.60.980.060.630.04875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control27680.583214.98.080.012300378719115158.72.13.870.052.460.03814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2286821.863214.97.580.0123001350562159557.42.11.400.050.890.03850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2130482997511.6798.333214.97.610.0123001268382152460.31.51.470.040.940.02847.351243.571239.132151.7360.432259.510.941.47
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2171915701498.6791.333214.98.100.012300357818956165.22.54.010.062.560.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2315451465805.1894.823214.97.590.0123001315192157258.10.71.410.020.900.01849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control41569140316610.5889.423214.98.090.012300373819076160.22.43.890.062.490.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO251877161726013.8586.153214.97.580.0123001365262161256.31.01.370.020.870.01850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control6175816071518.5991.413214.98.100.012300363718995163.32.14.000.052.530.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO27140712911168.2491.763214.97.420.02230020121092201540.41.80.980.040.630.03875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control816841593915.4094.603214.98.080.012300376419093159.21.33.870.032.470.02814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control925042413913.6396.373214.98.090.012300371719056160.82.73.910.062.500.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1028612839220.7799.233214.98.100.012300358618965164.82.04.010.052.560.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO211126663163550.1649.843214.97.590.0123001324462157558.21.81.410.040.900.03849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2121060986746.9893.023214.97.590.0123001316412157458.41.61.420.040.910.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1314841415694.6595.353214.98.090.012300366819026162.42.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1412031138655.4094.603214.98.090.912300373719075160.22.23.890.052.480.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2151397123216511.8188.193214.97.590.0123001319392157458.21.51.420.040.900.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1723852350351.4798.533214.98.090.012300365819016162.72.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO218125911461138.9891.023214.97.600.0123001294382155459.21.51.440.040.920.02848.521274.411269.862154.9059.142262.560.921.44
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1914841474100.6799.333214.98.110.012300354718925166.12.24.040.052.580.03813.14345.19343.961888.76167.742069.642.604.07
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control21141813161027.1992.813214.98.090.012300372719065160.52.23.900.052.490.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2221341119214911.1188.893214.97.580.0123001375412162456.11.51.360.040.870.02850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control23109185823321.3678.643214.98.090.012300369719045161.42.13.920.052.500.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control25845766799.3590.653214.98.100.012300360818977164.32.63.990.062.550.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2261988149249624.9575.053214.97.420.03230020631612201640.32.60.980.060.630.04875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2710551038171.6198.393214.98.080.012300378719115158.72.13.870.052.460.03814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2281755146429116.5883.423214.97.580.0123001350562159557.42.11.400.050.890.03850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2186.67283214.97.610.0123001268382152460.31.51.470.040.940.02847.351243.571239.132151.7360.432259.510.941.47
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control210.00823214.98.100.012300357818956165.22.54.010.062.560.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2380.00273214.97.590.0123001315192157258.10.71.410.020.900.01849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control450.003214.98.090.012300373819076160.22.43.890.062.490.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2580.00243214.97.580.0123001365262161256.31.01.370.020.870.01850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control626.67543214.98.100.012300363718995163.32.14.000.052.530.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO2713.333214.97.420.02230020121092201540.41.80.980.040.630.03875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control840.00443214.98.080.012300376419093159.21.33.870.032.470.02814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control956.67703214.98.090.012300371719056160.82.73.910.062.500.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1060.00393214.98.100.012300358618965164.82.04.010.052.560.03813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21173.33433214.97.590.0123001324462157558.21.81.410.040.900.03849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21253.333214.97.590.0123001316412157458.41.61.420.040.910.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1336.673214.98.090.012300366819026162.42.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1436.671023214.98.090.912300373719075160.22.23.890.052.480.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21550.003214.97.590.0123001319392157458.21.51.420.040.900.02849.721305.971301.312158.0057.882265.590.901.41
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1723.333214.98.090.012300365819016162.72.53.950.062.520.04813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO21856.67543214.97.600.0123001294382155459.21.51.440.040.920.02848.521274.411269.862154.9059.142262.560.921.44
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control1916.673214.98.110.012300354718925166.12.24.040.052.580.03813.14345.19343.961888.76167.742069.642.604.07
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2186.673214.98.090.012300372719065160.52.23.900.052.490.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO22290.003214.97.580.0123001375412162456.11.51.360.040.870.02850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2323.333214.98.090.012300369719045161.42.13.920.052.500.03813.87364.39363.091904.07161.492079.432.503.92
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control2530.00573214.98.100.012300360818977164.32.63.990.062.550.04813.50354.67353.411896.47164.592074.562.554.00
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO22653.33573214.97.420.03230020631612201640.32.60.980.060.630.04875.051971.101964.062202.0439.932317.020.620.97
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Control276.673214.98.080.012300378719115158.72.13.870.052.460.03814.25374.34373.011911.55158.432084.232.463.85
Gobiusculus flavescens (fish)Elevated CO22850.00453214.97.580.0123001350562159557.42.11.400.050.890.03850.951338.271333.492161.0356.642268.620.881.38