Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Miller, Garielle M; Kroon, F J; Metcalfe, Sarah; Munday, Philip L (2015): Temperature is the evil twin: Effects of increased temperature and ocean acidification on reproduction in a reef fish [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.836664, Supplement to: Miller, GM et al. (2014): Temperature is the evil twin: Effects of increased temperature and ocean acidification on reproduction in a reef fish. Ecological Applications, 25, 603-620, https://doi.org/10.1890/14-0559.1

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX Citation

Abstract:
Reproduction in many organisms can be disrupted by changes to the physical environment, such as those predicted to occur during climate change. Marine organisms face the dual climate change threats of increasing temperature and ocean acidification, yet no studies have examined the potential interactive effects of these stressors on reproduction in marine fishes. We used a long-term experiment to test the interactive effects of increased temperature and CO2 on the reproductive performance of the anemonefish, Amphiprion melanopus. Adult breeding pairs were kept for 10 months at three temperatures, 28.5°C (+0.0°C), 30.0°C (+1.5°C) and 31.5°C (+3.0°C), cross-factored with 3 CO2 levels, a current day control (417 µatm) and moderate (644 µatm) and high (1134 µatm) treatments consistent with the range of CO2 projections for the year 2100 under RCP8.5. We recorded each egg clutch produced during the breeding season, the number of eggs laid per clutch, average egg size, fertilization success, survival to hatching, hatchling length and yolk provisioning. Adult body condition, hepatosomatic index, gonadosomatic index, and plasma 17beta-estradiol concentrations were measured at the end of the breeding season to determine the effect of prolonged exposure to increased temperature and elevated CO2 on adults, and to examine potential physiological mechanisms for changes in reproduction. Temperature had by far the stronger influence on reproduction, with clear declines in reproduction occurring in the +1.5°C treatment and ceasing altogether in the +3.0°C treatment. In contrast, CO2 had a minimal effect on the majority of reproductive traits measured, but caused a decline in offspring quality in combination with elevated temperature. We detected no significant effect of temperature or CO2 on adult body condition or hepatosomatic index. Elevated temperature had a significant negative effect on plasma 17beta-estradiol concentrations, suggesting that declines in reproduction with increasing temperature were due to the thermal sensitivity of reproductive hormones rather than a reduction in energy available for reproduction. Our results show that elevated temperature exerts a stronger influence than high CO2 on reproduction in A. melanopus. Understanding how these two environmental variables interact to affect the reproductive performance of marine organisms will be important for predicting the future impacts of climate change.
Keyword(s):
Amphiprion melanopus; Animalia; Chordata; Coast and continental shelf; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Laboratory experiment; Nekton; Pelagos; Reproduction; Single species; South Pacific; Temperature; Tropical
Further details:
Lavigne, Héloïse; Epitalon, Jean-Marie; Gattuso, Jean-Pierre (2014): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 3.0. https://cran.r-project.org/package=seacarb
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne et al, 2014) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation is 2014-09-30.
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
SpeciesSpeciesMiller, Garielle M
FigureFigMiller, Garielle M
TreatmentTreatMiller, Garielle M
Temperature, waterTemp°CMiller, Garielle Mtreatment
MonthMonthMiller, Garielle M
Clutches per monthClutches/month#Miller, Garielle Mproduced
Reproductive pairsRepro pairs#Miller, Garielle M
Clutches per pairClutches/pair#Miller, Garielle M
Clutches per pair, standard errorClutches/pair std e±Miller, Garielle M
10 Eggs per clutchEggs/clutch#Miller, Garielle M
11 Eggs per clutch, standard errorEggs/clutch std e±Miller, Garielle M
12 Eggs areaEggs Amm2Miller, Garielle M
13 Eggs area, standard errorEggs A std e±Miller, Garielle M
14 Reproductive output per clutchRepro/clutchmm2Miller, Garielle M
15 Reproductive output per clutch, standard errorRepro/clutch std e±Miller, Garielle M
16 Clutches, survived to hatchingClutches survived hatch%Miller, Garielle M
17 Clutches, survived to hatching , standard errorClutches survived hatch std e±Miller, Garielle M
18 Eggs survived to hatchingEggs survived hatch%Miller, Garielle M
19 Eggs survived to hatching, standard errorEggs survived hatch std e±Miller, Garielle M
20 Hatchling lengthHatchling lmmMiller, Garielle M
21 Hatchling length, standard errorHatchling l std e±Miller, Garielle M
22 Yolk areaYolk Amm2Miller, Garielle M
23 Yolk area, standard errorYolk A std e±Miller, Garielle M
24 Condition indexCIMiller, Garielle MFulton's K body
25 Condition index, standard errorCI std e±Miller, Garielle MFulton's K body
26 Hepatosomatic indexHSIMiller, Garielle M
27 Hepatosomatic index, standard errorHSI std e±Miller, Garielle M
28 Gonadosomatic indexGSIMiller, Garielle M
29 Gonadosomatic index, standard errorGSI std e±Miller, Garielle M
30 Plasma 17beta-estradiol concentrationPlasma 17-estradiol concpg/mlMiller, Garielle M
31 Plasma 17beta-estradiol concentration, standard errorPlasma 17b-estradiol conc std e±Miller, Garielle M
32 pHpHMiller, Garielle MPotentiometricNBS scale
33 pH, standard errorpH std e±Miller, Garielle MPotentiometricNBS scale
34 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmMiller, Garielle MCalculated using CO2SYS
35 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air), standard errorpCO2water_SST_wet std e±Miller, Garielle MCalculated using CO2SYS
36 Temperature, waterTemp°CMiller, Garielle M
37 Temperature, water, standard errorT std e±Miller, Garielle M
38 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgMiller, Garielle MPotentiometric titration
39 Alkalinity, total, standard errorAT std e±Miller, Garielle MPotentiometric titration
40 SalinitySalMiller, Garielle M
41 Salinity, standard errorSal std e±Miller, Garielle M
42 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgMiller, Garielle MCalculated using CO2SYS
43 Bicarbonate ion, standard error[HCO3]- std e±Miller, Garielle MCalculated using CO2SYS
44 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
45 pHpHYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)total scale
46 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
47 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
48 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
49 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
50 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
51 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
52 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
53 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
Status:
Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)
Size:
2364 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


Species

Fig

Treat

Temp [°C]
(treatment)

Month

Clutches/month [#]
(produced)

Repro pairs [#]

Clutches/pair [#]

Clutches/pair std e [±]
10 
Eggs/clutch [#]
11 
Eggs/clutch std e [±]
12 
Eggs A [mm2]
13 
Eggs A std e [±]
14 
Repro/clutch [mm2]
15 
Repro/clutch std e [±]
16 
Clutches survived hatch [%]
17 
Clutches survived hatch std e [±]
18 
Eggs survived hatch [%]
19 
Eggs survived hatch std e [±]
20 
Hatchling l [mm]
21 
Hatchling l std e [±]
22 
Yolk A [mm2]
23 
Yolk A std e [±]
24 
CI
(Fulton's K body)
25 
CI std e [±]
(Fulton's K body)
26 
HSI
27 
HSI std e [±]
28 
GSI
29 
GSI std e [±]
30 
Plasma 17-estradiol conc [pg/ml]
31 
Plasma 17b-estradiol conc std e [±]
32 
pH
(NBS scale, Potentiometric)
33 
pH std e [±]
(NBS scale, Potentiometric)
34 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
35 
pCO2water_SST_wet std e [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
36 
Temp [°C]
37 
T std e [±]
38 
AT [µmol/kg]
(Potentiometric titration)
39 
AT std e [±]
(Potentiometric titration)
40 
Sal
41 
Sal std e [±]
42 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
43 
[HCO3]- std e [±]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
44 
CSC flag
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
45 
pH
(total scale, Calculated using...)
46 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
47 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
48 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
49 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
50 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
51 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
52 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
53 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control28.5November848.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO228.5November758.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO228.5November847.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control30.0November348.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO230.0November218.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO230.0November547.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control31.5November228.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO231.5November128.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO231.5November327.780.00811912731.50.012169733.620.0919026267.6328.521167.491164.091906.89106.812042.221.772.64
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control28.5December748.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO228.5December1058.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO228.5December847.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control30.0December448.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO230.0December118.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO230.0December747.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control31.5December128.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO231.5December128.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO231.5December127.780.00811912731.50.012169733.620.0919026267.6328.521167.491164.091906.89106.812042.221.772.64
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control28.5January648.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO228.5January858.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO228.5January747.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control30.0January148.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO230.0January118.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO230.0January947.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control31.5January028.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO231.5January028.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO231.5January027.780.00811912731.50.012169733.620.0919026267.6328.521167.491164.091906.89106.812042.221.772.64
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control28.5February848.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO228.5February1358.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO228.5February947.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control30.0February848.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO230.0February018.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO230.0February1047.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control31.5February028.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO231.5February028.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO231.5February027.780.00811912731.50.012169733.620.0919026267.6328.521167.491164.091906.89106.812042.221.772.64
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control28.5March748.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO228.5March1058.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO228.5March747.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control30.0March748.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO230.0March018.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO230.0March747.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control31.5March028.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO231.5March028.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO231.5March027.780.00811912731.50.012169733.620.0919026267.6328.521167.491164.091906.89106.812042.221.772.64
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control28.5April448.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO228.5April758.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO228.5April447.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control30.0April448.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO230.0April018.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO230.0April447.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Control31.5April028.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2Moderate CO231.5April128.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)2High CO231.5April027.780.00811912731.50.012169733.620.0919026267.6328.521167.491164.091906.89106.812042.221.772.64
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3Control28.59.000.8101166402.10.00924468292.64.4646.64.528.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3Moderate CO228.511.001.1401022362.10.00822258894.93.2238.12.588.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3High CO228.59.752.460872492.10.008187410686.49.4029.13.497.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3Control30.06.501.322765701.90.015146313778.015.707.31.628.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3Moderate CO230.04.000.0006732191.80.03112204220.00.000.00.008.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3High CO230.010.252.620781511.90.009150811050.317.307.51.937.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3Control31.51.500.5002801161.60.02744820525.025.000.00.008.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3Moderate CO231.51.500.5003342291.60.0245383670.00.000.00.008.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)3High CO231.52.000.0001201.60.0651900.00.000.00.007.780.00811912731.50.012169733.620.0919026267.6328.521167.491164.091906.89106.812042.221.772.64
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)4Control28.53.240.010.4230.0048.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)4Moderate CO228.53.290.010.4060.0078.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)4High CO228.53.120.010.3930.0047.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)4Control30.03.150.010.4090.0088.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)4Moderate CO230.08.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)4High CO230.03.030.030.3960.0087.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5Control28.54.890.121.110.061.030.3623138078.150.005400628.40.0120581633.320.12159211268.0010.54401.33400.121588.31188.521787.373.084.63
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5Moderate CO228.55.130.081.140.074.251.1733143708.000.0076341328.50.0121521032.700.12177610267.8516.85641.05639.111787.51148.271952.632.433.66
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5High CO228.55.120.121.120.111.721.0022444617.810.00810872528.50.012168733.620.0919075267.6627.611055.241052.051910.31104.772042.701.712.57
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5Control30.04.940.071.040.100.860.4717817928.140.005411629.80.0220641633.320.12157510267.9910.59416.71415.471586.33191.961788.883.164.73
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5Moderate CO230.05.090.121.060.050.950.20166715258.000.0066421230.10.012117732.700.1217377267.8516.12636.44634.561743.04151.761910.922.513.76
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5High CO230.05.040.051.160.113.390.86345919967.790.00811262429.80.022167733.620.0919035267.6428.481121.801118.461911.17104.122043.771.712.56
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5Control31.54.980.101.170.070.750.407915368.120.005441731.40.0220771633.320.12158511267.9710.96447.16445.851596.42193.511800.903.214.79
Amphiprion melanopus (fish)5Moderate CO231.55.130.211.350.110.520.087791378.000.0076581331.50.012130832.700.1217387267.8515.85645.87643.991741.16158.071915.082.643.94
3.591.200.950.070.790.121057245