Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Movilla, Juancho; Gori, Andrea; Calvo, Eva; Orejas, Covadonga; Lopez-Sanz, Angel; Domínguez-Carrió, Carlos; Grinyó, Jordi; Pelejero, Carles (2014): Seawater carbonate chemistry and calcification of two mediterranean cold-water coral species in a laboratory experiment [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.833187, Supplement to: Movilla, J et al. (2014): Resistance of Two Mediterranean Cold-Water Coral Species to Low-pH Conditions. Water, 6(1), 59-67, https://doi.org/10.3390/w6010059

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX Citation

Abstract:
Deep-water ecosystems are characterized by relatively low carbonate concentration values and, due to ocean acidification (OA), these habitats might be among the first to be exposed to undersaturated conditions in the forthcoming years. However, until now, very few studies have been conducted to test how cold-water coral (CWC) species react to such changes in the seawater chemistry. The present work aims to investigate the mid-term effect of decreased pH on calcification of the two branching CWC species most widely distributed in the Mediterranean, Lophelia pertusa and Madrepora oculata. No significant effects were observed in the skeletal growth rate, microdensity and porosity of both species after 6 months of exposure. However, while the calcification rate of M. oculata was similar for all colony fragments, a heterogeneous skeletal growth pattern was observed in L. pertusa, the younger nubbins showing higher growth rates than the older ones. A higher energy demand is expected in these young, fast-growing fragments and, therefore, a reduction in calcification might be noticed earlier during long-term exposure to acidified conditions.
Keyword(s):
Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Calcification/Dissolution; Cnidaria; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Deep-sea; Growth/Morphology; Laboratory experiment; Lophelia pertusa; Madrepora oculata; Mediterranean Sea; Single species; Temperate
Further details:
Lavigne, Héloïse; Epitalon, Jean-Marie; Gattuso, Jean-Pierre (2014): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 3.0. https://cran.r-project.org/package=seacarb
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne et al, 2014) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation is 2014-06-05.
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
Incubation durationInc durdaysMovilla, Juancho
TreatmentTreatMovilla, Juancho
IdentificationIDMovilla, Juancho
Calcification rate of calcium carbonateCalc rate CaCO3mg/g/dayMovilla, Juancho
SpeciesSpeciesMovilla, Juancho
MassMassgMovilla, Juanchoinitial
pHpHMovilla, JuanchoSpectrophotometrictotal scale
pH, standard deviationpH std dev±Movilla, JuanchoSpectrophotometrictotal scale
Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgMovilla, JuanchoPotentiometric titration
10 Alkalinity, total, standard deviationAT std dev±Movilla, JuanchoPotentiometric titration
11 SalinitySalMovilla, Juancho
12 Salinity, standard deviationSal std dev±Movilla, Juancho
13 Temperature, waterTemp°CMovilla, Juancho
14 Temperature, water, standard deviationTemp std dev±Movilla, Juancho
15 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetppmvMovilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
16 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide, standard deviationpCO2 std dev±Movilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
17 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgMovilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
18 Carbon, inorganic, dissolved, standard deviationDIC std dev±Movilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
19 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgMovilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
20 Carbon dioxide, standard deviationCO2 std dev±Movilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
21 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgMovilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
22 Bicarbonate ion, standard deviation[HCO3]- std dev±Movilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
23 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgMovilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
24 Carbonate ion, standard deviation[CO3]2- std dev±Movilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
25 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalMovilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
26 Calcite saturation state, standard deviationOmega Cal std dev±Movilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
27 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgMovilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
28 Aragonite saturation state, standard deviationOmega Arg std dev±Movilla, JuanchoCalculated using CO2calc
29 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
30 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
31 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
32 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
33 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
34 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
35 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
36 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
37 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
Status:
Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)
Size:
8700 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


Inc dur [days]

Treat

ID

Calc rate CaCO3 [mg/g/day]

Species

Mass [g]
(initial)

pH
(total scale, Spectrophotometric)

pH std dev [±]
(total scale, Spectrophotometric)

AT [µmol/kg]
(Potentiometric titration)
10 
AT std dev [±]
(Potentiometric titration)
11 
Sal
12 
Sal std dev [±]
13 
Temp [°C]
14 
Temp std dev [±]
15 
pCO2water_SST_wet [ppmv]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
16 
pCO2 std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
17 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
18 
DIC std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
19 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
20 
CO2 std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
21 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
22 
[HCO3]- std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
23 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
24 
[CO3]2- std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
25 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using CO2calc)
26 
Omega Cal std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
27 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using CO2calc)
28 
Omega Arg std dev [±]
(Calculated using CO2calc)
29 
CSC flag
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
30 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
31 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
32 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
33 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
34 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
35 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
36 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
37 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
62control191.7586Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control131.8129Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control12.1854Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control72.8383Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control201.5656Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control22.6073Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control142.6815Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control82.5424Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control151.9327Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control32.8864Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control91.0353Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control210.7596Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62low pH161.6734Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH101.0692Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH222.0419Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH40.5778Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH51.2256Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH111.8057Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH173.4271Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH230.4838Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH61.5216Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH122.5289Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH181.6386Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH242.1538Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118control19-0.2861Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control131.7981Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control11.8537Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control73.8049Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control202.0980Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control22.8489Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control143.5591Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control82.1019Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control152.5570Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control33.5363Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control91.0744Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control211.0418Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118low pH163.0624Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH101.2012Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH222.1788Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH40.9396Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH50.8862Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH111.9347Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH172.3352Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH230.4860Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH61.7169Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH122.6152Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH181.7992Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH241.9756Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182control190.9471Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control131.7623Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control11.7643Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control72.6288Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control201.4315Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control22.1949Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control142.5176Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control81.5677Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control152.3162Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control33.0428Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control91.5467Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control211.0232Lophelia pertusa (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182low pH163.1561Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH101.3210Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH222.5870Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH41.3758Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH51.1219Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH111.5663Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH172.2541Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH230.5058Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH62.5968Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH123.0244Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH182.1293Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH242.3094Lophelia pertusa (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62control150.7082Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control210.4311Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control420.5121Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control121.1811Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control250.9097Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control280.4094Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control230.5215Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control221.0783Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control460.7550Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control301.0233Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control310.6156Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control41.1596Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control202.0840Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control180.8525Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control540.8765Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control391.5897Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control261.3080Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62control190.3171Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
62low pH551.4403Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH450.8317Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH10.7574Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH170.9475Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH360.3339Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH320.3523Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH501.7608Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH110.5650Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH510.9213Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH490.9516Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH50.8156Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH80.5000Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH141.2926Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH130.7366Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH340.7805Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH480.4391Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH32.1972Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
62low pH401.3559Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118control150.3310Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control210.3467Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control420.3659Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control121.2058Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control250.6542Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control280.2843Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control230.5923Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control221.1194Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control460.7170Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control301.4109Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control310.3332Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control41.7742Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control201.7075Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control180.8058Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control540.1180Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control391.1791Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control260.6744Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118control190.2080Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
118low pH551.4624Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH450.7991Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH11.1321Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH170.7644Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH360.2834Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH320.5883Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH502.3681Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH111.1339Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH510.7257Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH491.1782Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH51.0492Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH80.6939Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH141.3199Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH130.5452Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH341.2370Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH480.7887Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH32.0766Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
118low pH401.5088Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182control150.6153Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control210.6289Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control420.6402Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control120.9412Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control250.7034Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control281.3553Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control230.6466Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control221.6621Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control460.8922Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control301.9037Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control310.4036Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control41.8115Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control202.5485Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control181.1511Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control540.6497Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control392.3015Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control260.8675Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control190.3148Madrepora oculata (coral)8.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182low pH551.3034Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH451.0699Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH11.7375Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH171.0934Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH360.4367Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH320.8968Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH502.1755Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH111.5574Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH510.4881Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH490.7218Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH50.8668Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH80.7692Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH141.0649Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH130.8152Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH341.5798Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH480.7404Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH31.5478Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH401.7971Madrepora oculata (coral)7.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182control190.8437Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.69258.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control131.7906Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.57598.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control11.9352Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.01638.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control73.0619Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.58738.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control201.6822Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.77078.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control22.5366Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.60748.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control142.8938Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.86428.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control82.0640Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.84808.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control152.2596Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.71158.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control33.1413Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.46668.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control91.2272Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.55888.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control210.9391Lophelia pertusa (coral)2.93828.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182low pH162.6220Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.72717.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH101.1984Lophelia pertusa (coral)2.06727.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH222.2757Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.77757.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH40.9696Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.27317.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH51.0847Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.72207.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH111.7612Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.45487.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH172.6785Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.85657.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH230.4922Lophelia pertusa (coral)2.60427.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH61.9597Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.19267.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH122.7297Lophelia pertusa (coral)0.78127.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH181.8605Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.59047.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH242.1536Lophelia pertusa (coral)1.30927.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182control150.5595Madrepora oculata (coral)0.55378.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control210.4747Madrepora oculata (coral)1.06728.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control420.5122Madrepora oculata (coral)0.55878.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control121.1043Madrepora oculata (coral)0.93718.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control250.7585Madrepora oculata (coral)0.48348.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control280.7034Madrepora oculata (coral)0.38708.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control230.5873Madrepora oculata (coral)1.09958.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control221.2962Madrepora oculata (coral)0.67268.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control460.7915Madrepora oculata (coral)1.09558.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control301.4521Madrepora oculata (coral)0.48468.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control310.4541Madrepora oculata (coral)0.90468.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control41.5779Madrepora oculata (coral)2.59168.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control202.1314Madrepora oculata (coral)0.74318.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control180.9431Madrepora oculata (coral)1.25428.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control540.5634Madrepora oculata (coral)0.57118.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control391.7135Madrepora oculata (coral)0.35118.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control260.9581Madrepora oculata (coral)0.57148.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182control190.2827Madrepora oculata (coral)1.72248.0920.02225401337.60.112.30.33842322861615.40.920872018474.30.22.80.1815385384208918322872.744.28
182low pH551.3990Madrepora oculata (coral)0.51517.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH450.9054Madrepora oculata (coral)0.51257.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH11.2172Madrepora oculata (coral)1.65907.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH170.9424Madrepora oculata (coral)1.75427.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH360.3545Madrepora oculata (coral)1.12677.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH320.6164Madrepora oculata (coral)0.78057.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH502.0935Madrepora oculata (coral)0.84647.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH111.0889Madrepora oculata (coral)1.03397.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH510.7088Madrepora oculata (coral)0.43957.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH490.9405Madrepora oculata (coral)0.47987.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH50.9055Madrepora oculata (coral)1.71017.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH80.6543Madrepora oculata (coral)1.97807.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH141.2209Madrepora oculata (coral)0.98017.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH130.7054Madrepora oculata (coral)1.14757.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH341.2020Madrepora oculata (coral)0.78087.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH480.6526Madrepora oculata (coral)0.52827.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH31.9317Madrepora oculata (coral)1.14677.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44
182low pH401.5581Madrepora oculata (coral)0.26627.8080.03125411237.60.112.30.28096124201832.42.622832110572.50.21.60.1832810807228410424211.562.44