Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Tatters, Avery O; Schnetzer, Astrid; Fu, Feixue; Lie, Alle Y A; Caron, David A; Hutchins, David A (2013): Short- versus long-term responses to changing CO2 in a coastal dinoflagellate bloom [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.823381, Supplement to: Tatters, AO et al. (2013): Short- versus long-term responses to changing CO2 in a coastal dinoflagellate bloom: implications for interspecific competitive interactions and community structure. Evolution, 67(7), 1879-1891, https://doi.org/10.1111/evo.12029

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX Citation

Abstract:
Increasing pCO2 (partial pressure of CO2 ) in an "acidified" ocean will affect phytoplankton community structure, but manipulation experiments with assemblages briefly acclimated to simulated future conditions may not accurately predict the long-term evolutionary shifts that could affect inter-specific competitive success. We assessed community structure changes in a natural mixed dinoflagellate bloom incubated at three pCO2 levels (230, 433, and 765 ppm) in a short-term experiment (2 weeks). The four dominant species were then isolated from each treatment into clonal cultures, and maintained at all three pCO2 levels for approximately 1 year. Periodically (4, 8, and 12 months), these pCO2 -conditioned clones were recombined into artificial communities, and allowed to compete at their conditioning pCO2 level or at higher and lower levels. The dominant species in these artificial communities of CO2 -conditioned clones differed from those in the original short-term experiment, but individual species relative abundance trends across pCO2 treatments were often similar. Specific growth rates showed no strong evidence for fitness increases attributable to conditioning pCO2 level. Although pCO2 significantly structured our experimental communities, conditioning time and biotic interactions like mixotrophy also had major roles in determining competitive outcomes. New methods of carrying out extended mixed species experiments are needed to accurately predict future long-term phytoplankton community responses to changing pCO2 .
Keyword(s):
Alexandrium sp.; Biomass/Abundance/Elemental composition; Bottles or small containers/Aquaria (<20 L); Chromista; Coast and continental shelf; Gonyaulax sp.; Growth/Morphology; Laboratory experiment; Lingulodinium polyedrum; Myzozoa; North Pacific; Pelagos; Phytoplankton; Prorocentrum micans; Species interaction; Temperate; Tropical
Further details:
Lavigne, Héloïse; Gattuso, Jean-Pierre (2011): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 2.4. https://cran.r-project.org/package=seacarb
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne and Gattuso, 2011) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation by seacarb is 2013-11-28.
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
SpeciesSpeciesTatters, Avery O
IdentificationIDTatters, Avery O
Incubation durationInc durdaysTatters, Avery O
Incubation durationInc durmonthsTatters, Avery O
TreatmentTreatTatters, Avery O
ReplicateReplTatters, Avery O
Growth rateµ1/dayTatters, Avery O
Cell densityCells#/mlTatters, Avery O
SalinitySalTatters, Avery O
10 Temperature, waterTemp°CTatters, Avery O
11 pHpHTatters, Avery OPotentiometricNBS scale
12 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgTatters, Avery OCoulometric titration
13 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmTatters, Avery OCalculated using CO2SYS
14 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
15 pHpHYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)total scale
16 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
17 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
18 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
19 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
20 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
21 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
22 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
23 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
24 pHpHTatters, Avery OpH meterswitched, NBS scale
25 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgTatters, Avery OCoulometryswitched
26 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmTatters, Avery OCalculated using CO2SYSswitched
27 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
28 pHpHYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched, total scale
29 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
30 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
31 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
32 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
33 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
34 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
35 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
36 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalYang, YanCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)switched
Status:
Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)
Size:
5616 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


Species

ID

Inc dur [days]

Inc dur [months]

Treat

Repl

µ [1/day]

Cells [#/ml]

Sal
10 
Temp [°C]
11 
pH
(NBS scale, Potentiometric)
12 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Coulometric titration)
13 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
14 
CSC flag
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
15 
pH
(total scale, Calculated using...)
16 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
17 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
18 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
19 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
20 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
21 
AT [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
22 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
23 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
24 
pH
(switched, NBS scale, pH meter)
25 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(switched, Coulometry)
26 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(switched, Calculated using CO...)
27 
CSC flag
(switched, Calculated using se...)
28 
pH
(switched, total scale, Calcul...)
29 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(switched, Calculated using se...)
30 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(switched, Calculated using se...)
31 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(switched, Calculated using se...)
32 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(switched, Calculated using se...)
33 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(switched, Calculated using se...)
34 
AT [µmol/kg]
(switched, Calculated using se...)
35 
Omega Arg
(switched, Calculated using se...)
36 
Omega Cal
(switched, Calculated using se...)
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2A0.2016535188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2B0.2215335188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2C0.2112935188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2A0.1714235188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2B0.1413735188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2C0.1612435188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2A0.1623135187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2B0.1825435187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2C0.1321235187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2A0.281235188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2B0.241735188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2C0.01335188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2A0.111035188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2B0.141335188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2C0.10735188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2A0.222735187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2B0.233235187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2C0.304235187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2A0.05135188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2B0.35235188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2C0.35435188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2A0.07635188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2B0.12235188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2C0.261135188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2A0.373635187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2B0.252935187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2C0.242435187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2A0.41335188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2B0.35635188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Low pCO2C0.24135188.381971230278.268223222170525923423.996.17
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2A0.294135188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2B0.213635188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14Medium pCO2C0.212235188.152067433278.0314418417188416823002.604.02
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2A0.545235187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2B0.534335187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Initial natural community incubation14High pCO2C0.474535187.942162765277.8225730727202611123011.722.66
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2A14235188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2B24835188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2C18335188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2A7035188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2B7535188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2C4735188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2A4335187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2B3035187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2C3535187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2A24435188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2B13235188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2C14435188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2A6935188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2B10235188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2C14435188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2A9635187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2B11635187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2C13835187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2A12635188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2B17435188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2C15835188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2A13035188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2B17635188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2C9635188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2A15235187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2B18035187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2C20635187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2A30035188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2B28435188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Low pCO2C29835188.252048336278.1311323322183120623383.184.91
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2A24035188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2B16835188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8Medium pCO2C22235188.132125469278.0115452450194416623522.563.96
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2A30535187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2B32735187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination8High pCO2C33635187.962190731277.8424704702204811823391.822.82
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2A0.0935188.311987280278.199269268175222623103.495.40
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2B0.1635188.311987280278.199269268175222623103.495.40
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2C0.1135188.311987280278.199269268175222623103.495.40
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2A0.1235188.142078450278.0215431430189816623072.563.95
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2B0.1135188.142078450278.0215431430189816623072.563.95
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2C0.1035188.142078450278.0215431430189816623072.563.95
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2A0.0835187.952216760277.8325730728207411723611.802.79
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2B0.1035187.952216760277.8325730728207411723611.802.79
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2C0.0935187.952216760277.8325730728207411723611.802.79
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2A0.0735188.282023305278.1610296295179621623303.345.16
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2B0.0735188.282023305278.1610296295179621623303.345.16
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2C0.0635188.282023305278.1610296295179621623303.345.16
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2A0.0735188.152150448278.0315435434196017523902.704.18
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2B0.0835188.152150448278.0315435434196017523902.704.18
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2C0.0735188.152150448278.0315435434196017523902.704.18
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2A0.0735187.932209792277.8126764761207111123461.722.66
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2B0.0735187.932209792277.8126764761207111123461.722.66
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2C0.0735187.932209792277.8126764761207111123461.722.66
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2A0.1335188.301995286278.189277276176322223133.435.31
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2B0.1535188.301995286278.189277276176322223133.435.31
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2C0.1535188.301995286278.189277276176322223133.435.31
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2A0.2035188.132118466278.0115451449193716523442.553.94
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2B0.2035188.132118466278.0115451449193716523442.553.94
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2C0.1935188.132118466278.0115451449193716523442.553.94
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2A0.2635187.942192762277.8225740737205411323321.742.70
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2B0.2235187.942192762277.8225740737205411323321.742.70
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2C0.2435187.942192762277.8225740737205411323321.742.70
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2A0.1235188.272022310278.1510303302180021223233.275.06
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2B0.1035188.272022310278.1510303302180021223233.275.06
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Low pCO2C0.1135188.272022310278.1510303302180021223233.275.06
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2A0.1135188.102138501277.9817490488196515623502.413.73
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2B0.1435188.102138501277.9817490488196515623502.413.73
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8Medium pCO2C0.1135188.102138501277.9817490488196515623502.413.73
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2A0.1435187.932224786277.8126769766208611223611.732.68
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2B0.1135187.932224786277.8126769766208611223611.732.68
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Unialgal cultures8High pCO2C0.1535187.932224786277.8126769766208611223611.732.68
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2A-0.063035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2B0.1418035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2C0.049035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2A0.154035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2B0.288035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2C0.144035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2A-0.071035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2B0.253035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2C0.004035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2A0.3413035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2B0.5012035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2C0.4110035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2A0.4121035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2B0.4031035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2C0.5822035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2A0.5010035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2B0.4216035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2C0.4015035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2A0.137035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2B0.185035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2C0.3510035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2A0.223035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2B0.259035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2C0.374035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2A0.5010035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2B0.4414035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2C0.439035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2A0.3562035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2B0.5064035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Low pCO2C0.3433035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2A0.3635035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2B0.2934035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12Medium pCO2C0.3241035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2A0.2320035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2B0.2421035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Artificial community recombination12High pCO2C0.2332035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.2410035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2B0.277535188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.285335188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2A0.322335188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2B0.352735188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2C0.311535188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.1018035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.096235188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.2327335188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2A0.103235188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2B0.277735188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2C0.252135188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.424035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.271035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.234735187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.22635187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2B-0.033335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Lingulodinium polyedrum (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.032535187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.5653035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2B0.4917335188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.6136735188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2A0.493835188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2B0.3824335188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2C0.416735188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.7164335188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.7013735188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.6557035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2A0.7414835188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2B0.7873335188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2C0.7422735188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.5241035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.568735187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.6153035187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.5415435187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2B0.6052335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Alexandrium sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.6913435187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.4411735188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2B0.661535188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.6724735188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2A0.775535188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2B0.4413735188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2C0.483235188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.0023035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.129235188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.4125335188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2A0.138335188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2B0.5735335188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2C0.461235188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.3429335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.386835187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.3617335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.333135187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2B0.3725735187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Gonyaulax sp. (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.309335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.527335188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2B0.482535188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.475335188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.038.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2A0.473235188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2B0.3911035188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Low pCO2 to High pCO2C0.472635188.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.037.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.4410035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.445235188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.668035188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.988.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2A0.304635188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2B0.276735188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12Medium pCO2 to High pCO2C0.404735188.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.987.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.86
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2A0.4011335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2B0.275535187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Low pCO2C0.4015335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.272011305278.1510302300179021123113.255.03
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2A0.332535187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2B0.2711335187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98
Prorocentrum micans (phytoplankton)Switch experiments12High pCO2 to Medium pCO2C0.365535187.972174709277.8523683680203112023261.852.868.142091451278.0215434432191016723212.573.98