Citation:

j.1365-2486.2012.02695.x

Name: Calcification rate of massive Porites spp. and Porites rus in the experiment of Moorea
Published: 2012
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
Keywords: Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Calcification/Dissolution; Cnidaria; Coast and continental shelf; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Laboratory experiment; Porites rus; Porites sp.; Single species; South Pacific; Temperature; Tropical

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS Citation BibTeX Citation Text Citation Facebook TwitterShow Map Google Earth

Abstract:

This study tested the hypothesis that the response of corals to temperature and pCO2 is consistent between taxa. Juvenile massive Porites spp. and branches of P. rus from the back reef of Moorea were incubated for 1 month under combinations of temperature (29.3 °C and 25.6 °C) and pCO2 (41.6 Pa and 81.5 Pa) at an irradiance of 599 µmol quanta/m/s. Using microcosms and CO2 gas mixing technology, treatments were created in a partly nested design (tanks) with two between-plot factors (temperature and pCO2), and one within-plot factor (taxon); calcification was used as a dependent variable. pCO2 and temperature independently affected calcification, but the response differed between taxa. Massive Porites spp. was largely unaffected by the treatments, but P. rus grew 50% faster at 29.3 °C compared with 25.6 °C, and 28% slower at 81.5 Pa vs. 41.6 Pa CO2. A compilation of studies placed the present results in a broader context and tested the hypothesis that calcification for individual coral genera is independent of pH, [HCO3]-, and [CO3]2-. Unlike recent reviews, this analysis was restricted to studies reporting calcification in units that could be converted to nmol CaCO3/cm**2/h. The compilation revealed a high degree of variation in calcification as a function of pH, [HCO3]-, and [CO3]2-, and supported three conclusions: (1) studies of the effects of ocean acidification on corals need to pay closer attention to reducing variance in experimental outcomes to achieve stronger synthetic capacity, (2) coral genera respond in dissimilar ways to pH, [HCO3]-, and [CO3]2-, and (3) calcification of massive Porites spp. is relatively resistant to short exposures of increased pCO2, similar to that expected within 100 y.

Keyword(s):

Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Calcification/Dissolution; Cnidaria; Coast and continental shelf; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Laboratory experiment; Porites rus; Porites sp.; Single species; South Pacific; Temperature; Tropical

Further details:

Lavigne, Héloïse; Gattuso, Jean-Pierre (2011): seacarb: seawater carbonate chemistry with R. R package version 2.4. https://cran.r-project.org/package=seacarb

Project(s):

Ocean Acidification International Coordination Centre (OA-ICC)

Coverage:

Latitude: -17.476900 * Longitude: -149.815300

Date/Time Start: 2011-04-01T00:00:00 * Date/Time End: 2011-08-31T00:00:00

Minimum Elevation: -4.0 m * Maximum Elevation: -2.0 m

Event(s):

Moorea * Latitude: -17.476900 * Longitude: -149.815300 * Date/Time Start: 2011-04-01T00:00:00 * Date/Time End: 2011-08-31T00:00:00 * Elevation Start: -2.0 m * Elevation End: -4.0 m * Location: French Polynesia * Method/Device: Experiment (EXP)

Comment:

In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne and Gattuso, 2011) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI). The date of carbonate chemistry calculation by seacarb is 2013-11-29.

Parameter(s):

#	Name	Short Name	Unit	Principal Investigator	Method/Device	Comment
1	Treatment	Treat		Edmunds, Peter J		HT-HCO2=High Temp High CO2, HT-LCO2=High Temp Low CO2, LT-HCO2=Low Temp High CO2, LT-LCO2=Low Temp Low CO2
2	Species	Species		Edmunds, Peter J
3	Sample ID	Sample ID		Edmunds, Peter J
4	Sample code/label	Sample label		Edmunds, Peter J
5	Surface area	SA	cm²	Edmunds, Peter J
6	Calcification rate of calcium carbonate	Calc rate CaCO3	mg/cm²/day	Edmunds, Peter J
7	Temperature, water	Temp	°C	Edmunds, Peter J		Temperature in tank
8	Temperature, water	Temp	°C	Edmunds, Peter J		Laboratory temperature
9	Salinity	Sal		Edmunds, Peter J
10	pH	pH		Edmunds, Peter J	Spectrophotometric	pH measured at laboratory temperature, total scale. Standard error less than 0.1
11	Alkalinity, total	AT	µmol/kg	Edmunds, Peter J	Potentiometric titration
12	Alkalinity, total, standard error	AT std e	±	Edmunds, Peter J	Potentiometric titration
13	Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	pCO2water_SST_wet	Pa	Edmunds, Peter J	Calculated using CO2SYS
14	Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air), standard error	pCO2water_SST_wet std e	±	Edmunds, Peter J	Calculated using CO2SYS
15	Aragonite saturation state	Omega Arg		Edmunds, Peter J	Calculated using CO2SYS
16	Aragonite saturation state, standard error	Omega Arg std e	±	Edmunds, Peter J	Calculated using CO2SYS
17	Carbonate system computation flag	CSC flag		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
18	pH	pH		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)	In situ pH, total scale
19	Carbon dioxide	CO2	µmol/kg	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
20	Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	pCO2water_SST_wet	µatm	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
21	Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	fCO2water_SST_wet	µatm	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
22	Bicarbonate ion	[HCO3]-	µmol/kg	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
23	Carbonate ion	[CO3]2-	µmol/kg	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
24	Carbon, inorganic, dissolved	DIC	µmol/kg	Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
25	Aragonite saturation state	Omega Arg		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
26	Calcite saturation state	Omega Cal		Yang, Yan	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)

License:

Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported (CC-BY-3.0)

Status:

Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)

Size:

2080 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:

1 Treat (HT-HCO2=High Temp High CO2, H...)	2 Species	3 Sample ID	4 Sample label	5 SA [cm²]	6 Calc rate CaCO3 [mg/cm²/day]	7 Temp [°C] (Temperature in tank)	8 Temp [°C] (Laboratory temperature)	9 Sal	10 pH (pH measured at laboratory tem...)	11 AT [µmol/kg] (Potentiometric titration)	12 AT std e [±] (Potentiometric titration)	13 pCO2water_SST_wet [Pa] (Calculated using CO2SYS)	14 pCO2water_SST_wet std e [±] (Calculated using CO2SYS)	15 Omega Arg (Calculated using CO2SYS)	16 Omega Arg std e [±] (Calculated using CO2SYS)	17 CSC flag (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	18 pH (In situ pH, total scale, Calc...)	19 CO2 [µmol/kg] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	20 pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	21 fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	22 [HCO3]- [µmol/kg] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	23 [CO3]2- [µmol/kg] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	24 DIC [µmol/kg] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	25 Omega Arg (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	26 Omega Cal (Calculated using seacarb afte...)
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 1	Tank 2	17.961	1.282	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 3	Tank 2	34.466	1.203	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 6	Tank 1	17.233	0.545	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 7	Tank 5	38.592	1.346	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 16	Tank 2	21.602	1.028	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 17	Tank 7	20.146	1.167	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 18	Tank 1	12.136	0.823	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 19	Tank 6	25.971	1.368	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 23	Tank 5	14.806	0.741	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 24	Tank 4	17.233	1.207	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 27	Tank 8	18.447	0.871	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 28	Tank 6	19.903	1.241	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 29	Tank 8	11.165	0.910	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 30	Tank 4	18.447	1.059	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 31	Tank 6	23.058	0.962	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 32	Tank 7	17.961	1.083	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 36	Tank 4	18.932	0.684	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 38	Tank 3	16.748	1.539	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 42	Tank 7	19.903	0.828	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 43	Tank 6	22.816	0.939	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 49	Tank 8	28.155	0.943	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 50	Tank 1	35.922	0.804	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 52	Tank 8	28.398	1.120	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 55	Tank 5	27.670	0.765	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 56	Tank 5	21.845	0.849	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 58	Tank 3	25.000	0.561	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 64	Tank 6	25.485	0.989	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 65	Tank 1	20.631	0.567	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 66	Tank 3	43.932	0.763	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 68	Tank 5	23.786	0.998	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 73	Tank 3	33.981	1.316	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 74	Tank 8	24.272	0.977	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 75	Tank 2	12.379	0.293	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 77	Tank 4	30.340	1.058	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 79	Tank 4	32.524	1.037	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 80	Tank 7	16.505	1.002	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
HT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 82	Tank 3	20.874	1.023	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
HT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 83	Tank 2	19.175	0.858	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
LT-LCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 84	Tank 7	10.437	0.979	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites spp.	Coral 85	Tank 1	24.515	1.022	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 86	Tank 5	11.711	1.655	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 87	Tank 7	15.793	2.151	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 90	Tank 4	10.881	2.621	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 91	Tank 1	10.151	1.776	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 92	Tank 3	12.142	2.296	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 93	Tank 6	17.618	0.614	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 95	Tank 7	11.943	2.684	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 96	Tank 1	13.569	1.180	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 97	Tank 2	12.208	3.302	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 98	Tank 2	3.812	7.301	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 99	Tank 5	14.167	1.013	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 100	Tank 6	16.689	2.151	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 101	Tank 4	16.091	2.780	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 102	Tank 6	10.715	2.233	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 103	Tank 3	9.620	1.980	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 104	Tank 8	11.843	1.842	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 105	Tank 1	16.457	1.852	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 106	Tank 6	22.961	1.779	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 107	Tank 1	14.133	1.770	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 108	Tank 8	19.676	1.565	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 109	Tank 3	15.859	2.440	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 110	Tank 8	11.379	1.811	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 111	Tank 5	9.520	1.363	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 112	Tank 3	14.266	1.432	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 113	Tank 1	9.387	1.466	25.4	25.0	34.4	7.74	2135	24	86.5	2.2	1.75	0.05	8	7.73	24.1	857.3	854.6	1863.5	109.4	1997.0	1.75	2.65
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 114	Tank 7	13.503	1.444	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 115	Tank 2	19.510	2.432	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 116	Tank 2	14.930	1.964	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 117	Tank 7	21.899	2.166	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 118	Tank 6	11.943	2.198	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2054	49	84.1	2.2	1.89	0.07	8	7.74	20.7	809.6	807.1	1751.3	121.2	1893.2	1.97	2.95
HT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 119	Tank 3	11.578	1.687	29.3	25.2	34.7	7.80	2089	44	81.2	5.3	2.07	0.16	8	7.74	21.0	823.8	821.3	1782.1	123.4	1926.5	2.00	3.00
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 120	Tank 4	11.412	1.789	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 121	Tank 8	7.861	0.852	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 122	Tank 5	19.842	1.685	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
LT-HCO2	Porites rus	Coral 123	Tank 5	16.324	1.038	25.7	24.9	34.3	7.73	2064	35	87.0	3.4	1.67	0.05	8	7.72	24.1	863.3	860.6	1806.4	103.2	1933.7	1.65	2.50
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 124	Tank 7	10.549	1.480	25.7	24.8	34.3	7.99	2038	42	43.0	1.0	2.64	0.09	8	7.98	11.9	427.0	425.6	1618.0	167.4	1797.3	2.68	4.06
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 125	Tank 4	15.859	2.873	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
LT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 126	Tank 8	12.308	1.287	25.5	24.7	34.4	7.99	2046	45	43.2	1.0	2.63	0.10	8	7.98	12.0	426.7	425.4	1624.9	167.9	1804.8	2.68	4.06
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 127	Tank 4	12.408	2.000	29.4	25.2	34.5	8.02	1982	53	43.7	1.3	2.87	0.13	8	7.96	11.1	433.3	432.0	1540.2	175.2	1726.5	2.85	4.27
HT-LCO2	Porites rus	Coral 128	Tank 2	16.556	2.478	29.2	25.4	34.7	8.02	1981	60	43.3	0.7	2.91	0.15	8	7.96	10.9	425.3	424.0	1535.2	176.6	1722.7	2.87	4.30