Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Talmage, Stephanie C; Gobler, Christopher J (2009): Seawater carbonate chemistry and survival of mollusks: Mercenaria mercenaria, Argopecten irradians, and Crassostrea virginica during experiments, 2009 [dataset]. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.756661, Supplement to: Talmage, SC; Gobler, CJ (2009): The effects of elevated carbon dioxide concentrations on the metamorphosis, size, and survival of larval hard clams (Mercenaria mercenaria), bay scallops (Argopecten irradians), and Eastern oysters (Crassostrea virginica). Limnology and Oceanography, 54(6), 2072-2080, https://doi.org/10.4319/lo.2009.54.6.2072

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX Citation

Abstract:
We present experiments that examined the metamorphosis, growth, and survivorship of larvae from three species of commercially and ecologically valuable shellfish (Mercenaria mercenaria, Argopecten irradians, and Crassostrea virginica) at the levels of CO2 projected to occur during the 21st century and beyond. Under CO2 concentrations estimated to occur later this century (~66 Pa, 650 ppm), M. mercenaria and A. irradians larvae exhibited dramatic declines (>50%) in survivorship as well as significantly delayed metamorphosis and significantly smaller sizes. Although C. virginica larvae also experienced lowered growth and delayed metamorphosis at ~66 Pa CO2, their survival was only diminished at ~152 Pa CO2. The extreme sensitivity of larval stages of shellfish to enhanced levels of CO2 indicates that current and future increases in pelagic CO2 concentrations may deplete or alter the composition of shellfish populations in coastal ecosystems.
Keyword(s):
Animalia; Argopecten irradians; Bottles or small containers/Aquaria (<20 L); Crassostrea virginica; Development; Laboratory experiment; Mercenaria mercenaria; Mollusca; Mortality/Survival; North Atlantic; Pelagos; Single species; Zooplankton
Funding:
Seventh Framework Programme (FP7), grant/award no. 211384: European Project on Ocean Acidification
Sixth Framework Programme (FP6), grant/award no. 511106: European network of excellence for Ocean Ecosystems Analysis
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne and Gattuso, 2011) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI).
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
SpeciesSpeciesTalmage, Stephanie C
Experimental treatmentExp treatTalmage, Stephanie C
Experiment dayExp daydayTalmage, Stephanie C
SalinitySalTalmage, Stephanie C
Salinity, standard deviationSal std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
Temperature, waterTemp°CTalmage, Stephanie C
Temperature, standard deviationT std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
pHpHTalmage, Stephanie CpH meterTotal scale, hydrogen ion concentration in µmol/l
pH, standard deviationpH std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
10 Carbon dioxide, partial pressurepCO2PaTalmage, Stephanie CCalculated using CO2SYS
11 Carbon dioxide, partial pressure, standard deviationpCO2 std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
12 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalTalmage, Stephanie CCalculated using CO2SYS
13 Calcite saturation state, standard deviationOmega Cal std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
14 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgTalmage, Stephanie CCalculated using CO2SYS
15 Aragonite saturation state, standard deviationOmega Arg std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
16 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/lTalmage, Stephanie CEGM-4 Environmental Gas Analyzer (PP Systems) using a Liqui-CelH Membrane (Membr
17 Carbon, inorganic, dissolved, standard deviationDIC std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
18 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/lTalmage, Stephanie CCalculated using CO2SYS
19 Carbon dioxide, standard deviationCO2 std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
20 Alkalinity, totalATmmol(eq)/lTalmage, Stephanie CCalculated using CO2SYS
21 Alkalinity, total, standard deviationAT std dev±Talmage, Stephanie C
22 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
23 pHpHNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)Total scale, hydrogen ion concentration in µmol/kg
24 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
25 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
26 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
27 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
28 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
29 Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
30 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
31 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
32 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
33 Veliger, larvaeVeliger larv%Talmage, Stephanie C
34 Pediveliger, larvaePediveliger larv%Talmage, Stephanie C
35 Metamorphosed, larvaeMetamorph larv%Talmage, Stephanie C
36 SurvivalSurvival%Talmage, Stephanie C
37 MortalityMortality%Talmage, Stephanie C
Status:
Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)
Size:
2461 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


Species

Exp treat

Exp day [day]

Sal

Sal std dev [±]

Temp [°C]

T std dev [±]

pH
(Total scale, hydrogen ion con...)

pH std dev [±]
10 
pCO2 [Pa]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
11 
pCO2 std dev [±]
12 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
13 
Omega Cal std dev [±]
14 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
15 
Omega Arg std dev [±]
16 
DIC [µmol/l]
(EGM-4 Environmental Gas Analy...)
17 
DIC std dev [±]
18 
[CO3]2- [µmol/l]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
19 
CO2 std dev [±]
20 
AT [mmol(eq)/l]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
21 
AT std dev [±]
22 
CSC flag
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
23 
pH
(Total scale, hydrogen ion con...)
24 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
25 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
26 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
27 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
28 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
29 
DIC [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
30 
AT [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
31 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
32 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
33 
Veliger larv [%]
34 
Pediveliger larv [%]
35 
Metamorph larv [%]
36 
Survival [%]
37 
Mortality [%]
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO24281240.527.490.021150181.330.1210.850.12018501595481.8880.02097.3657.851920.871914.751724.1834.631816.71810.60.570.88100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO27281240.527.490.021150181.330.1210.850.12018501595481.8880.02097.3657.851920.871914.751724.1834.631816.71810.60.570.8899.271.100.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO211281240.527.490.021150181.330.1210.850.12018501595481.8880.02097.3657.851920.871914.751724.1834.631816.71810.60.570.8822.7146.523.3072.53
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO214281240.527.490.021150181.330.1210.850.12018501595481.8880.02097.3657.851920.871914.751724.1834.631816.71810.60.570.881.4722.347.6931.50
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO218281240.527.490.021150181.330.1210.850.12018501595481.8880.02097.3657.851920.871914.751724.1834.631816.71810.60.570.880.005.8618.6824.54-6.3
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO24281240.527.840.0426482.980.6231.920.421185024912132.0020.02197.7026.30873.33870.551715.0075.361816.71901.51.231.91100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO27281240.527.840.0426482.980.6231.920.421185024912132.0020.02197.7026.30873.33870.551715.0075.361816.71901.51.231.9189.921.210.0091.13
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO211281240.527.840.0426482.980.6231.920.421185024912132.0020.02197.7026.30873.33870.551715.0075.361816.71901.51.231.9125.4044.763.3073.46
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO214281240.527.840.0426482.980.6231.920.421185024912132.0020.02197.7026.30873.33870.551715.0075.361816.71901.51.231.910.8118.556.0525.40
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO218281240.527.840.0426482.980.6231.920.421185024912132.0020.02197.7026.30873.33870.551715.0075.361816.71901.51.231.910.001.6112.9014.52-6.7
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO24281240.528.020.0213643.680.2222.370.124158010915051.7920.07997.8814.60484.84483.301441.0795.851551.51684.41.572.43100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO27281240.528.020.0213643.680.2222.370.124158010915051.7920.07997.8814.60484.84483.301441.0795.851551.51684.41.572.4399.180.820.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO211281240.528.020.0213643.680.2222.370.124158010915051.7920.07997.8814.60484.84483.301441.0795.851551.51684.41.572.4321.4370.607.97100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO214281240.528.020.0213643.680.2222.370.124158010915051.7920.07997.8814.60484.84483.301441.0795.851551.51684.41.572.430.0016.7668.9685.71
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO218281240.528.020.0213643.680.2222.370.124158010915051.7920.07997.8814.60484.84483.301441.0795.851551.51684.41.572.430.000.0075.8275.82-1.8
Crassostrea virginicaHigh_pCO23281240.517.500.01215051.430.1210.920.0321920415871.9610.03997.3660.041993.561987.201789.4235.941885.41878.50.590.91100.000.000.00100.00
Crassostrea virginicaHigh_pCO26281240.517.500.01215051.430.1210.920.0321920415871.9610.03997.3660.041993.561987.201789.4235.941885.41878.50.590.9183.850.000.0083.85
Crassostrea virginicaHigh_pCO210281240.517.500.01215051.430.1210.920.0321920415871.9610.03997.3660.041993.561987.201789.4235.941885.41878.50.590.9164.100.380.0064.49
Crassostrea virginicaHigh_pCO214281240.517.500.01215051.430.1210.920.0321920415871.9610.03997.3660.041993.561987.201789.4235.941885.41878.50.590.9122.6924.742.9550.38
Crassostrea virginicaHigh_pCO217281240.517.500.01215051.430.1210.920.0321920415871.9610.03997.3660.041993.561987.201789.4235.941885.41878.50.590.910.0012.1827.0539.23
Crassostrea virginicaHigh_pCO220281240.517.500.01215051.430.1210.920.0321920415871.9610.03997.3660.041993.561987.201789.4235.941885.41878.50.590.910.0015.0020.3835.38-3.9
Crassostrea virginicaMid_pCO23281240.527.850.0316352.970.2331.910.11118401812141.9960.05497.7125.55848.30845.601704.6476.651806.81894.51.251.94100.000.000.00100.00
Crassostrea virginicaMid_pCO26281240.527.850.0316352.970.2331.910.11118401812141.9960.05497.7125.55848.30845.601704.6476.651806.81894.51.251.9482.260.000.0082.26
Crassostrea virginicaMid_pCO210281240.527.850.0316352.970.2331.910.11118401812141.9960.05497.7125.55848.30845.601704.6476.651806.81894.51.251.9475.272.020.0077.28
Crassostrea virginicaMid_pCO214281240.527.850.0316352.970.2331.910.11118401812141.9960.05497.7125.55848.30845.601704.6476.651806.81894.51.251.9418.9551.346.0576.34
Crassostrea virginicaMid_pCO217281240.527.850.0316352.970.2331.910.11118401812141.9960.05497.7125.55848.30845.601704.6476.651806.81894.51.251.940.0043.5525.9469.49
Crassostrea virginicaMid_pCO220281240.527.850.0316352.970.2331.910.11118401812141.9960.05497.7125.55848.30845.601704.6476.651806.81894.51.251.940.0018.8242.0760.89-1.9
Crassostrea virginicaAmbient_pCO23281240.528.070.0123624.520.2412.910.123177067180252.0140.01297.9214.84492.83491.261606.13117.131738.11896.31.912.97100.000.000.00100.00
Crassostrea virginicaAmbient_pCO26281240.528.070.0123624.520.2412.910.123177067180252.0140.01297.9214.84492.83491.261606.13117.131738.11896.31.912.9799.880.000.0099.88
Crassostrea virginicaAmbient_pCO210281240.528.070.0123624.520.2412.910.123177067180252.0140.01297.9214.84492.83491.261606.13117.131738.11896.31.912.9785.294.780.0090.07
Crassostrea virginicaAmbient_pCO214281240.528.070.0123624.520.2412.910.123177067180252.0140.01297.9214.84492.83491.261606.13117.131738.11896.31.912.975.9841.5114.8362.32
Crassostrea virginicaAmbient_pCO217281240.528.070.0123624.520.2412.910.123177067180252.0140.01297.9214.84492.83491.261606.13117.131738.11896.31.912.970.0022.2531.3453.59
Crassostrea virginicaAmbient_pCO220281240.528.070.0123624.520.2412.910.123177067180252.0140.01297.9214.84492.83491.261606.13117.131738.11896.31.912.970.005.1443.7848.92-3.5
Argopecten irradiansHigh_pCO25281240.537.480.061163271.410.1230.910.1201980545762.0110.02497.3563.342103.102096.391844.7736.211944.31934.00.590.92100.000.000.00100.00
Argopecten irradiansHigh_pCO28281240.537.480.061163271.410.1230.910.1201980545762.0110.02497.3563.342103.102096.391844.7736.211944.31934.00.590.9299.620.000.0099.62
Argopecten irradiansHigh_pCO212281240.537.480.061163271.410.1230.910.1201980545762.0110.02497.3563.342103.102096.391844.7736.211944.31934.00.590.920.0032.0821.4653.54
Argopecten irradiansHigh_pCO216281240.537.480.061163271.410.1230.910.1201980545762.0110.02497.3563.342103.102096.391844.7736.211944.31934.00.590.920.003.856.6710.51
Argopecten irradiansHigh_pCO219281240.537.480.061163271.410.1230.910.1201980545762.0110.02497.3563.342103.102096.391844.7736.211944.31934.00.590.920.001.542.313.85-7.9
Argopecten irradiansMid_pCO25281240.537.840.0326952.900.2401.870.12119001511832.0470.03097.7027.01896.94894.081761.3577.401865.81951.91.261.96100.000.000.00100.00
Argopecten irradiansMid_pCO28281240.537.840.0326952.900.2401.870.12119001511832.0470.03097.7027.01896.94894.081761.3577.401865.81951.91.261.9699.410.000.0099.41
Argopecten irradiansMid_pCO212281240.537.840.0326952.900.2401.870.12119001511832.0470.03097.7027.01896.94894.081761.3577.401865.81951.91.261.960.0048.4315.1663.58
Argopecten irradiansMid_pCO216281240.537.840.0326952.900.2401.870.12119001511832.0470.03097.7027.01896.94894.081761.3577.401865.81951.91.261.960.002.959.8912.84
Argopecten irradiansMid_pCO219281240.537.840.0326952.900.2401.870.12119001511832.0470.03097.7027.01896.94894.081761.3577.401865.81951.91.261.960.001.572.564.13-7.8
Argopecten irradiansAmbient_pCO25281240.538.080.0343634.800.4203.060.341183066194262.0870.05197.9314.98497.25495.671658.29123.751797.01962.82.023.14100.000.000.00100.00
Argopecten irradiansAmbient_pCO28281240.538.080.0343634.800.4203.060.341183066194262.0870.05197.9314.98497.25495.671658.29123.751797.01962.82.023.1499.810.000.0099.81
Argopecten irradiansAmbient_pCO212281240.538.080.0343634.800.4203.060.341183066194262.0870.05197.9314.98497.25495.671658.29123.751797.01962.82.023.140.0053.5429.2982.84
Argopecten irradiansAmbient_pCO216281240.538.080.0343634.800.4203.060.341183066194262.0870.05197.9314.98497.25495.671658.29123.751797.01962.82.023.140.000.0059.3359.33
Argopecten irradiansAmbient_pCO219281240.538.080.0343634.800.4203.060.341183066194262.0870.05197.9314.98497.25495.671658.29123.751797.01962.82.023.140.000.0051.8751.87-3.8
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO24281240.527.790.0127322.570.1231.660.042183012105101.9610.01897.6529.27971.97968.871701.1266.621797.01866.61.091.69100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO27281240.527.790.0127322.570.1231.660.042183012105101.9610.01897.6529.27971.97968.871701.1266.621797.01866.61.091.69100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO211281240.527.790.0127322.570.1231.660.042183012105101.9610.01897.6529.27971.97968.871701.1266.621797.01866.61.091.6913.1131.050.5744.73
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO213281240.527.790.0127322.570.1231.660.042183012105101.9610.01897.6529.27971.97968.871701.1266.621797.01866.61.091.691.1421.3710.2632.76
Mercenaria mercenariaHigh_pCO215281240.527.790.0127322.570.1231.660.042183012105101.9610.01897.6529.27971.97968.871701.1266.621797.01866.61.091.690.008.5511.4019.94-8.2
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO24281240.517.880.0216043.150.1012.030.1021850812962.0200.03497.7423.92794.32791.791710.3382.411816.71914.01.352.09100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO27281240.517.880.0216043.150.1012.030.1021850812962.0200.03497.7423.92794.32791.791710.3382.411816.71914.01.352.0997.980.000.0097.98
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO211281240.517.880.0216043.150.1012.030.1021850812962.0200.03497.7423.92794.32791.791710.3382.411816.71914.01.352.0920.0055.071.3776.43
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO213281240.517.880.0216043.150.1012.030.1021850812962.0200.03497.7423.92794.32791.791710.3382.411816.71914.01.352.090.0047.8119.9567.76
Mercenaria mercenariaMid_pCO215281240.517.880.0216043.150.1012.030.1021850812962.0200.03497.7423.92794.32791.791710.3382.411816.71914.01.352.090.0028.9633.3362.30-3.8
Mercenaria mercenariaLow_pCO24281240.527.970.0224924.000.2222.580.12219106116352.1260.03497.8319.92661.31659.201751.82103.841875.62006.21.702.63100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaLow_pCO27281240.527.970.0224924.000.2222.580.12219106116352.1260.03497.8319.92661.31659.201751.82103.841875.62006.21.702.63100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaLow_pCO211281240.527.970.0224924.000.2222.580.12219106116352.1260.03497.8319.92661.31659.201751.82103.841875.62006.21.702.6317.2354.856.8078.88
Mercenaria mercenariaLow_pCO213281240.527.970.0224924.000.2222.580.12219106116352.1260.03497.8319.92661.31659.201751.82103.841875.62006.21.702.630.0057.5213.8371.36
Mercenaria mercenariaLow_pCO215281240.527.970.0224924.000.2222.580.12219106116352.1260.03497.8319.92661.31659.201751.82103.841875.62006.21.702.630.0026.4639.0865.53-3.5
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO24281240.528.020.0124124.140.1332.670.11118001616912.0360.00597.8816.64552.36550.601641.73109.191767.61911.81.782.77100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO27281240.528.020.0124124.140.1332.670.11118001616912.0360.00597.8816.64552.36550.601641.73109.191767.61911.81.782.77100.000.000.00100.00
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO211281240.528.020.0124124.140.1332.670.11118001616912.0360.00597.8816.64552.36550.601641.73109.191767.61911.81.782.7721.9365.807.0594.78
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO213281240.528.020.0124124.140.1332.670.11118001616912.0360.00597.8816.64552.36550.601641.73109.191767.61911.81.782.770.0050.3937.8688.25
Mercenaria mercenariaAmbient_pCO215281240.528.020.0124124.140.1332.670.11118001616912.0360.00597.8816.64552.36550.601641.73109.191767.61911.81.782.770.0032.1153.7985.90-1.4