Not logged in
PANGAEA.
Data Publisher for Earth & Environmental Science

Gutowska, Magdalena A; Pörtner, Hans-Otto; Melzner, Frank (2008): Seawater carbonate chemistry and biological processes during experiments with common cuttlefish Sepia officinalis, 2010. PANGAEA, https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.737457, In supplement to: Gutowska, MA et al. (2008): Growth and calcification in the cephalopod Sepia officinalis under elevated seawater pCO2. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 373, 303-309, https://doi.org/10.3354/meps07782

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS CitationBibTeX Citation

Abstract:
Ocean acidification and associated changes in seawater carbonate chemistry negatively influence calcification processes and depress metabolism in many calcifying marine invertebrates. We present data on the cephalopod mollusc Sepia officinalis, an invertebrate that is capable of not only maintaining calcification, but also growth rates and metabolism when exposed to elevated partial pressures of carbon dioxide (pCO2). During a 6 wk period, juvenile S. officinalis maintained calcification under ~4000 and ~6000 ppm CO2, and grew at the same rate with the same gross growth efficiency as did control animals. They gained approximately 4% body mass daily and increased the mass of their calcified cuttlebone by over 500%. We conclude that active cephalopods possess a certain level of pre-adaptation to long-term increments in carbon dioxide levels. Our general understanding of the mechanistic processes that limit calcification must improve before we can begin to predict what effects future ocean acidification will have on calcifying marine invertebrates.
Keyword(s):
Animalia; Calcification/Dissolution; Coast and continental shelf; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Growth/Morphology; Laboratory experiment; Mediterranean Sea; Mollusca; Nekton; Pelagos; Sepia officinalis; Single species; Temperate
Funding:
Seventh Framework Programme (FP7), grant/award no. 211384: European Project on Ocean Acidification
Sixth Framework Programme (FP6), grant/award no. 511106: European network of excellence for Ocean Ecosystems Analysis
Comment:
In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne and Gattuso, 2011) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI).
Parameter(s):
#NameShort NameUnitPrincipal InvestigatorMethod/DeviceComment
IdentificationIDGutowska, Magdalena AGroup
Experimental treatmentExp treatGutowska, Magdalena A
Experiment dayExp daydayGutowska, Magdalena A
SalinitySalGutowska, Magdalena A
Temperature, waterTemp°CGutowska, Magdalena A
Temperature, standard deviationT std dev±Gutowska, Magdalena A
pHpHGutowska, Magdalena AWTW Oxi 340i probeNBS scale
pH, standard deviationpH std dev±Gutowska, Magdalena A
Carbon, inorganic, dissolvedDICµmol/kgGutowska, Magdalena AGas chromatography
10 Carbon, inorganic, dissolved, standard deviationDIC std dev±Gutowska, Magdalena A
11 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmGutowska, Magdalena ACalculated using CO2SYS
12 Carbon dioxide, partial pressure, standard deviationpCO2 std dev±Gutowska, Magdalena A
13 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgGutowska, Magdalena ACalculated using CO2SYS
14 Carbonate system computation flagCSC flagNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
15 pHpHNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)Total scale
16 Carbon dioxideCO2µmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
17 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)pCO2water_SST_wetµatmNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
18 Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)fCO2water_SST_wetµatmNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
19 Bicarbonate ion[HCO3]-µmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
20 Carbonate ion[CO3]2-µmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
21 Alkalinity, totalATµmol/kgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
22 Aragonite saturation stateOmega ArgNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
23 Calcite saturation stateOmega CalNisumaa, Anne-MarinCalculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
24 IdentificationIDGutowska, Magdalena AAnimal
25 Sepia officinalis, mass, wetS. officinalis wmgGutowska, Magdalena AMeasuredInitial
26 Sepia officinalis, length, mantleS. officinalis lmmGutowska, Magdalena AMeasuredInitial
27 Sepia officinalis, mass, wetS. officinalis wmgGutowska, Magdalena AMeasuredFinal
28 Sepia officinalis, length, mantleS. officinalis lmmGutowska, Magdalena AMeasuredFinal
29 Time, incubationT incubationdayGutowska, Magdalena AMeasured
30 Sepia officinalis, cuttlebone, CaCO3, massS. officinalis cb CaCO3gGutowska, Magdalena AMeasured
Size:
4227 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:


ID
(Group)

Exp treat

Exp day [day]

Sal

Temp [°C]

T std dev [±]

pH
(NBS scale, WTW Oxi 340i probe)

pH std dev [±]

DIC [µmol/kg]
(Gas chromatography)
10 
DIC std dev [±]
11 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
12 
pCO2 std dev [±]
13 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using CO2SYS)
14 
CSC flag
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
15 
pH
(Total scale, Calculated using...)
16 
CO2 [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
17 
pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
18 
fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
19 
[HCO3]- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
20 
[CO3]2- [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
21 
AT [µmol/kg]
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
22 
Omega Arg
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
23 
Omega Cal
(Calculated using seacarb afte...)
24 
ID
(Animal)
25 
S. officinalis wm [g]
(Initial, Measured)
26 
S. officinalis l [mm]
(Initial, Measured)
27 
S. officinalis wm [g]
(Final, Measured)
28 
S. officinalis l [mm]
(Final, Measured)
29 
T incubation [day]
(Measured)
30 
S. officinalis cb CaCO3 [g]
(Measured)
Control group4000 ppm incubation32.816.320.127.940.062048976961091.48277.825.01688.51686.101928.0294.972164.11.472.30
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation32.916.370.127.230.0424524441914020.34277.1151.494179.064164.422278.5721.952332.30.340.53
Control group6000 ppm incubation31.417.450.168.010.04210453620671.79277.921.77614.82612.691968.85113.382246.71.782.77
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation32.317.430.157.100.0325834359565240.27277.0209.655947.165926.612356.2617.092397.70.270.42
Control group4000 ppm incubation12.9721.411.0237.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation23.3722.910.1435.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation32.3418.310.7835.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation42.5319.511.6136.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation52.3220.213.3740.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation63.2221.912.6539.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation72.6920.010.5435.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation82.9322.19.4434.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation92.1618.014.0341.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation102.8421.511.3437.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation112.7521.210.2137.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation122.4719.012.8738.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation132.5420.011.0437.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation142.5519.513.6039.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation152.8221.512.1637.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation162.4118.512.3638.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation172.9120.912.3639.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation182.1518.012.5937.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation192.8922.112.2538.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation203.0722.513.3239.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation212.6520.011.8436.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation222.3819.510.0735.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation232.7220.613.0038.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation242.3019.011.1936.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation252.9021.09.4634.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation262.5221.09.0334.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation272.8021.50
Control group4000 ppm incubation282.9221.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation292.9922.20
Control group4000 ppm incubation302.5821.20
Control group4000 ppm incubation13.1221.28
Control group4000 ppm incubation23.3622.28
Control group4000 ppm incubation33.4322.68
Control group4000 ppm incubation43.4623.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation52.9820.48
Control group4000 ppm incubation63.0321.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation73.9525.18
Control group4000 ppm incubation83.0621.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation93.5223.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation103.6623.28
Control group4000 ppm incubation113.4922.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation123.0521.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation133.6423.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation143.4123.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation152.7622.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation163.4323.28
Control group4000 ppm incubation173.2022.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation183.9023.98
Control group4000 ppm incubation193.2021.78
Control group4000 ppm incubation203.4122.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation213.4623.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation223.7924.58
Control group4000 ppm incubation233.8524.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation242.4620.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation253.0621.78
Control group4000 ppm incubation262.7821.28
Control group4000 ppm incubation273.5224.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation282.7120.28
Control group4000 ppm incubation292.8621.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation302.9522.08
Control group4000 ppm incubation14.3824.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation24.8726.716
Control group4000 ppm incubation33.2122.016
Control group4000 ppm incubation44.2124.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation54.0024.716
Control group4000 ppm incubation63.8525.016
Control group4000 ppm incubation73.8524.916
Control group4000 ppm incubation85.0228.816
Control group4000 ppm incubation94.7427.116
Control group4000 ppm incubation103.6725.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation115.1028.216
Control group4000 ppm incubation123.8425.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation133.6125.016
Control group4000 ppm incubation144.2625.016
Control group4000 ppm incubation154.6927.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation164.8127.016
Control group4000 ppm incubation174.9628.016
Control group4000 ppm incubation184.5127.716
Control group4000 ppm incubation194.7127.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation204.9728.316
Control group4000 ppm incubation214.1826.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation223.5223.216
Control group4000 ppm incubation234.7427.816
Control group4000 ppm incubation244.3127.016
Control group4000 ppm incubation254.5226.516
Control group4000 ppm incubation265.0729.216
Control group4000 ppm incubation274.5227.816
Control group4000 ppm incubation283.4423.716
Control group4000 ppm incubation2916
Control group4000 ppm incubation3016
Control group4000 ppm incubation15.1729.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation25.0027.824
Control group4000 ppm incubation34.9827.524
Control group4000 ppm incubation46.1130.324
Control group4000 ppm incubation56.1930.524
Control group4000 ppm incubation66.8033.224
Control group4000 ppm incubation76.4832.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation86.5632.524
Control group4000 ppm incubation95.5129.824
Control group4000 ppm incubation104.8627.224
Control group4000 ppm incubation114.1626.224
Control group4000 ppm incubation126.1831.324
Control group4000 ppm incubation135.4330.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation145.4630.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation156.0730.824
Control group4000 ppm incubation167.0533.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation174.6129.224
Control group4000 ppm incubation186.6431.524
Control group4000 ppm incubation195.6830.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation204.7529.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation214.5026.524
Control group4000 ppm incubation226.5232.524
Control group4000 ppm incubation235.7731.724
Control group4000 ppm incubation245.6631.224
Control group4000 ppm incubation256.2632.224
Control group4000 ppm incubation266.6032.024
Control group4000 ppm incubation2724
Control group4000 ppm incubation2824
Control group4000 ppm incubation2924
Control group4000 ppm incubation3024
Control group4000 ppm incubation111.0236.940
Control group4000 ppm incubation210.1435.040
Control group4000 ppm incubation310.7835.540
Control group4000 ppm incubation411.6136.440
Control group4000 ppm incubation513.3739.940
Control group4000 ppm incubation612.6539.040
Control group4000 ppm incubation710.5435.040
Control group4000 ppm incubation89.4434.040
Control group4000 ppm incubation914.0340.840
Control group4000 ppm incubation1011.3437.540
Control group4000 ppm incubation1110.2136.940
Control group4000 ppm incubation1212.8738.240
Control group4000 ppm incubation1311.0436.940
Control group4000 ppm incubation1413.6039.240
Control group4000 ppm incubation1512.1637.540
Control group4000 ppm incubation1612.3638.540
Control group4000 ppm incubation1712.3639.040
Control group4000 ppm incubation1812.5937.040
Control group4000 ppm incubation1912.2538.540
Control group4000 ppm incubation2013.3239.740
Control group4000 ppm incubation2111.8436.640
Control group4000 ppm incubation2210.0735.040
Control group4000 ppm incubation2313.0038.240
Control group4000 ppm incubation2411.1936.240
Control group4000 ppm incubation259.4634.540
Control group4000 ppm incubation269.0334.240
Control group4000 ppm incubation2740
Control group4000 ppm incubation2840
Control group4000 ppm incubation2940
Control group4000 ppm incubation3040
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation13.2423.38.2531.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation22.2018.69.6934.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation32.3518.510.5136.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation42.9520.69.8835.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation52.6019.514.8739.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation62.9122.011.9338.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation72.5319.29.8734.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation82.4719.210.9134.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation92.7018.910.4833.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation102.0517.011.1436.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation112.3718.912.5338.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation123.0522.011.5937.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation132.9423.010.3835.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation142.6121.011.6739.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation153.2823.210.0835.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation162.4320.410.6634.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation172.6121.89.8335.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation182.9122.09.7534.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation192.5820.312.7837.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation203.2823.710.2535.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation212.3619.512.7239.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation222.8020.813.2239.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation233.0022.211.2137.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation242.3519.511.3937.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation252.6220.711.5938.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation262.6720.511.9339.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation272.4819.812.5339.50
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation283.0722.29.5836.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation292.6020.812.9939.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation303.0422.310.5033.00
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation13.1822.78
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation23.9625.28
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation33.8623.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation42.8322.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation52.9922.28
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation62.8821.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation73.9225.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation83.7424.58
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation93.8323.78
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation103.2924.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation113.3623.28
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation123.1622.88
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation132.9320.98
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation144.2624.58
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation152.9621.88
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation163.6524.68
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation172.7320.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation183.7222.68
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation192.9222.58
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation204.0524.78
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation213.2522.58
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation223.1423.28
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation232.4918.88
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation243.3321.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation252.8620.88
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation263.3922.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation273.1421.58
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation283.0921.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation293.4023.08
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation303.9124.58
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation14.3125.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation24.5326.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation34.3026.716
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation44.1126.416
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation53.6424.216
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation63.9024.816
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation73.6824.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation85.0328.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation95.4630.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation103.9226.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation114.9328.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation125.0628.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation135.0128.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation144.4226.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation154.0426.216
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation164.0826.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation173.5825.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation183.9025.916
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation193.7125.016
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation205.1727.816
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation213.7424.916
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation225.2828.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation235.2528.216
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation244.2927.316
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation253.1222.216
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation264.9129.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation274.1226.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation284.4727.216
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation294.9527.516
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation304.0425.216
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation14.1125.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation25.2528.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation35.2229.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation44.9026.924
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation54.7428.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation65.7430.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation75.2029.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation86.5430.924
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation94.7927.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation105.1130.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation114.7028.224
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation124.9428.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation136.3632.224
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation146.8833.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation156.5731.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation166.6432.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation175.5430.124
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation185.5130.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation197.3633.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation205.3029.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation215.4928.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation226.9832.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation235.4730.524
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation245.6930.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation255.9330.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation265.4130.224
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation276.2831.824
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation286.2431.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation295.0628.024
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation306.8932.224
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation18.2531.040
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation29.6933.840
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation310.5136.240
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation49.8835.040
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation514.8739.540
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation611.9338.340
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation79.8733.940
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation810.9134.040
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation910.4833.240
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1011.1436.040
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1112.5338.240
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1211.5937.540
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1310.3834.940
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1411.6738.840
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1510.0835.240
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1610.6634.440
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation179.8335.540
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation189.7534.640
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1912.7837.240
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2010.2535.540
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2112.7239.040
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2213.2239.540
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2311.2136.940
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2411.3936.840
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2511.5938.140
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2611.9339.440
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2712.5339.540
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation289.5835.940
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2912.9939.040
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3010.5033.240
Control group6000 ppm incubation14.6528.015.2041.500.10
Control group6000 ppm incubation25.6431.013.6640.000.12
Control group6000 ppm incubation35.2328.518.1846.500.11
Control group6000 ppm incubation45.7529.520.6348.000.14
Control group6000 ppm incubation54.6428.024.5753.000.09
Control group6000 ppm incubation66.2431.019.7349.000.15
Control group6000 ppm incubation75.6130.524.1052.500.16
Control group6000 ppm incubation85.4829.529.6459.000.12
Control group6000 ppm incubation94.4928.034.5366.000.12
Control group6000 ppm incubation104.7928.519.3545.500.10
Control group6000 ppm incubation115.6630.024.1953.500.14
Control group6000 ppm incubation125.9031.523.0151.500.13
Control group6000 ppm incubation133.0823.524.8955.000.07
Control group6000 ppm incubation143.0523.028.9358.000.06
Control group6000 ppm incubation153.2725.525.0254.000.05
Control group6000 ppm incubation163.8025.023.1851.500.09
Control group6000 ppm incubation173.5426.524.4653.500.07
Control group6000 ppm incubation183.9826.528.4759.000.06
Control group6000 ppm incubation194.3928.029.3659.500.09
Control group6000 ppm incubation204.1628.031.8762.000.11
Control group6000 ppm incubation213.3924.524.1751.000.06
Control group6000 ppm incubation16.09284.210
Control group6000 ppm incubation25.17274.310
Control group6000 ppm incubation37.37313.410
Control group6000 ppm incubation49.19351.910
Control group6000 ppm incubation58.39358.210
Control group6000 ppm incubation66.33310.710
Control group6000 ppm incubation75.63291.510
Control group6000 ppm incubation87.96332.510
Control group6000 ppm incubation95.25279.710
Control group6000 ppm incubation109.82360.110
Control group6000 ppm incubation118.60347.510
Control group6000 ppm incubation129.55353.810
Control group6000 ppm incubation139.37358.310
Control group6000 ppm incubation147.32333.910
Control group6000 ppm incubation157.31338.710
Control group6000 ppm incubation166.11309.410
Control group6000 ppm incubation179.64353.010
Control group6000 ppm incubation189.04350.110
Control group6000 ppm incubation198.59322.410
Control group6000 ppm incubation206.37306.310
Control group6000 ppm incubation215.79268.510
Control group6000 ppm incubation114.59427.020
Control group6000 ppm incubation211.63394.620
Control group6000 ppm incubation38.05345.020
Control group6000 ppm incubation412.52410.520
Control group6000 ppm incubation511.28385.520
Control group6000 ppm incubation69.3820
Control group6000 ppm incubation714.00421.120
Control group6000 ppm incubation815.16436.420
Control group6000 ppm incubation911.80399.420
Control group6000 ppm incubation107.59343.820
Control group6000 ppm incubation119.56353.020
Control group6000 ppm incubation1211.88395.220
Control group6000 ppm incubation1310.24370.020
Control group6000 ppm incubation148.75358.920
Control group6000 ppm incubation1513.89421.520
Control group6000 ppm incubation1611.67390.120
Control group6000 ppm incubation1712.77404.120
Control group6000 ppm incubation1813.50414.120
Control group6000 ppm incubation198.01317.420
Control group6000 ppm incubation2013.89410.620
Control group6000 ppm incubation218.89358.920
Control group6000 ppm incubation116.29459.230
Control group6000 ppm incubation215.83440.130
Control group6000 ppm incubation315.84444.830
Control group6000 ppm incubation420.25503.330
Control group6000 ppm incubation514.08442.830
Control group6000 ppm incubation613.11411.630
Control group6000 ppm incubation713.42416.830
Control group6000 ppm incubation819.82472.130
Control group6000 ppm incubation920.09487.330
Control group6000 ppm incubation1018.15473.430
Control group6000 ppm incubation1117.14458.930
Control group6000 ppm incubation1217.22453.630
Control group6000 ppm incubation1311.98394.630
Control group6000 ppm incubation1410.42388.030
Control group6000 ppm incubation1523.61520.030
Control group6000 ppm incubation1621.68503.430
Control group6000 ppm incubation1719.92481.030
Control group6000 ppm incubation1816.70467.730
Control group6000 ppm incubation1918.18472.730
Control group6000 ppm incubation2016.73459.430
Control group6000 ppm incubation2110.54356.730
Control group6000 ppm incubation115.20415.0400.40
Control group6000 ppm incubation213.66400.3400.56
Control group6000 ppm incubation318.18465.0400.52
Control group6000 ppm incubation420.63480.0400.66
Control group6000 ppm incubation524.57530.0400.72
Control group6000 ppm incubation619.73490.0400.54
Control group6000 ppm incubation724.10525.0400.67
Control group6000 ppm incubation829.64590.0400.84
Control group6000 ppm incubation934.53660.0401.00
Control group6000 ppm incubation1019.35455.0400.52
Control group6000 ppm incubation1124.19535.0400.69
Control group6000 ppm incubation1223.01515.0400.70
Control group6000 ppm incubation1324.89550.0400.73
Control group6000 ppm incubation1428.93580.2400.85
Control group6000 ppm incubation1525.02540.0400.73
Control group6000 ppm incubation1623.18514.5400.68
Control group6000 ppm incubation1724.46535.0400.73
Control group6000 ppm incubation1828.47590.0400.89
Control group6000 ppm incubation1929.36595.0400.86
Control group6000 ppm incubation2031.87620.0400.91
Control group6000 ppm incubation2124.17510.0400.63
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation15.7530.023.7352.000.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation24.4929.019.4648.000.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation35.1030.021.7150.000.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation45.0028.516.8144.500.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation54.8129.517.7545.000.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation65.9030.020.0248.500.15
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation75.5728.017.7744.500.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation85.4831.023.5952.500.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation95.9131.521.4350.000.14
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation105.1029.516.2042.000.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation116.0330.524.7454.500.15
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation124.7427.524.2654.000.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation133.3524.528.8958.500.06
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation142.9623.524.0953.000.05
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation153.5125.030.2361.500.06
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation163.2926.022.0152.000.07
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation173.3725.525.3354.500.08
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation183.0626.023.0851.500.05
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation193.2224.529.1660.000.05
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation203.5727.524.9855.500.08
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation214.2828.529.0360.000.09
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation15.64303.810
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation25.78299.910
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation38.80348.210
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation45.97294.510
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation54.98275.910
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation610.04384.010
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation75.84308.610
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation88.34326.910
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation99.41351.110
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation107.70328.510
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation118.45360.010
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation128.59340.810
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation135.49286.210
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation149.34366.510
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation157.30309.410
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation169.68351.710
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation176.64286.510
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation187.60326.410
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation195.88287.510
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation209.69350.710
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation218.26328.910
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation112.66383.020
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation215.18448.320
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation311.92376.120
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation49.18357.020
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation58.19345.820
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation612.54398.920
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation78.81363.720
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation811.60386.720
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation912.10399.120
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1014.43416.920
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1114.29418.420
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1211.34369.220
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1314.46419.020
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1413.14417.420
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation159.54358.020
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1612.86386.920
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation179.85360.420
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1812.90401.320
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation199.36343.420
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation208.91346.020
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation219.14351.020
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation114.74430.730
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation212.40415.930
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation320.66485.130
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation418.61445.430
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation515.15423.530
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation613.34429.130
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation712.93392.130
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation821.83495.930
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation920.71484.630
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1017.82436.530
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1114.71427.930
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1217.10443.230
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1316.40430.030
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1416.68438.130
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1520.37480.330
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1611.92392.430
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1717.96455.030
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1817.40462.530
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1918.17460.030
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2012.84409.830
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2113.80427.730
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation123.73520.5400.80
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation219.46480.0400.68
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation321.71500.0400.68
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation416.81445.0400.59
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation517.75450.0400.61
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation620.02485.0400.63
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation717.77445.0400.65
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation823.59525.0400.77
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation921.43500.0400.76
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1016.20420.0400.61
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1124.74545.0400.88
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1224.26540.0400.84
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1328.89584.6401.00
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1424.09530.0400.84
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1530.23615.0401.10
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1622.01520.0400.79
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1725.33545.0400.87
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1823.08515.0400.89
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1929.16600.0400.93
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2024.98555.0400.91
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2129.03600.0401.02
Control group4000 ppm incubation016.208.04
Control group4000 ppm incubation116.208.01
Control group4000 ppm incubation216.208.00
Control group4000 ppm incubation316.307.98
Control group4000 ppm incubation416.307.97
Control group4000 ppm incubation516.207.97
Control group4000 ppm incubation616.207.95
Control group4000 ppm incubation716.407.93
Control group4000 ppm incubation816.507.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation916.507.90
Control group4000 ppm incubation1016.307.92
Control group4000 ppm incubation1116.207.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation1216.207.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation1316.307.94
Control group4000 ppm incubation1416.307.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation1516.307.90
Control group4000 ppm incubation1616.207.89
Control group4000 ppm incubation1716.307.92
Control group4000 ppm incubation1816.407.90
Control group4000 ppm incubation1916.407.90
Control group4000 ppm incubation2016.507.89
Control group4000 ppm incubation2116.307.92
Control group4000 ppm incubation2216.307.90
Control group4000 ppm incubation2316.307.93
Control group4000 ppm incubation2416.407.93
Control group4000 ppm incubation2516.407.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation2616.307.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation2716.307.89
Control group4000 ppm incubation2816.307.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation2916.307.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation3016.307.93
Control group4000 ppm incubation3116.207.92
Control group4000 ppm incubation3216.207.90
Control group4000 ppm incubation3316.407.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation3416.207.90
Control group4000 ppm incubation3516.207.88
Control group4000 ppm incubation3616.207.87
Control group4000 ppm incubation3716.307.94
Control group4000 ppm incubation3816.307.91
Control group4000 ppm incubation3916.307.89
Control group4000 ppm incubation4016.307.90
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation016.307.28
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation116.207.27
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation216.307.28
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation316.307.26
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation416.407.24
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation516.507.25
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation616.407.25
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation716.407.25
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation816.607.24
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation916.507.22
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1016.607.23
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1116.507.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1216.407.25
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1316.407.22
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1416.307.21
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1516.307.18
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1616.407.19
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1716.407.22
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1816.407.18
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation1916.407.17
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2016.307.19
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2116.207.22
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2216.307.21
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2316.307.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2416.507.23
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2516.407.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2616.407.19
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2716.307.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2816.507.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation2916.307.19
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3016.407.21
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3116.307.22
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3216.207.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3316.307.18
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3416.207.19
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3516.407.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3616.307.19
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3716.207.21
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3816.307.22
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation3916.207.20
CO2 group4000 ppm incubation4016.207.19
Control group6000 ppm incubation017.408.05
Control group6000 ppm incubation117.408.04
Control group6000 ppm incubation217.308.03
Control group6000 ppm incubation317.308.03
Control group6000 ppm incubation417.408.05
Control group6000 ppm incubation517.508.04
Control group6000 ppm incubation617.308.02
Control group6000 ppm incubation717.308.04
Control group6000 ppm incubation817.308.04
Control group6000 ppm incubation917.408.03
Control group6000 ppm incubation1017.208.03
Control group6000 ppm incubation1117.208.04
Control group6000 ppm incubation1217.208.02
Control group6000 ppm incubation1317.508.00
Control group6000 ppm incubation1417.608.03
Control group6000 ppm incubation1517.408.02
Control group6000 ppm incubation1617.407.99
Control group6000 ppm incubation1717.408.00
Control group6000 ppm incubation1817.508.01
Control group6000 ppm incubation1917.507.98
Control group6000 ppm incubation2017.407.98
Control group6000 ppm incubation2117.408.00
Control group6000 ppm incubation2217.508.01
Control group6000 ppm incubation2317.508.01
Control group6000 ppm incubation2417.508.02
Control group6000 ppm incubation2517.407.99
Control group6000 ppm incubation2617.507.98
Control group6000 ppm incubation2717.607.97
Control group6000 ppm incubation2817.607.98
Control group6000 ppm incubation2917.208.00
Control group6000 ppm incubation3017.607.99
Control group6000 ppm incubation3117.208.01
Control group6000 ppm incubation3217.308.00
Control group6000 ppm incubation3317.407.98
Control group6000 ppm incubation3417.308.02
Control group6000 ppm incubation3517.607.99
Control group6000 ppm incubation3617.507.97
Control group6000 ppm incubation3717.508.01
Control group6000 ppm incubation3817.607.98
Control group6000 ppm incubation3917.407.98
Control group6000 ppm incubation4017.507.96
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation017.307.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation117.507.15
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation217.407.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation317.507.14
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation417.307.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation517.307.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation617.207.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation717.507.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation817.507.14
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation917.207.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1017.507.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1117.207.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1217.307.10
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1317.407.13
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1417.707.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1517.307.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1617.307.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1717.207.09
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1817.507.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation1917.507.10
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2017.507.09
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2117.507.10
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2217.507.14
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2317.507.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2417.507.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2517.407.08
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2617.407.10
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2717.407.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2817.507.09
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation2917.407.10
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3017.607.08
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3117.407.07
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3217.307.12
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3317.407.10
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3417.407.09
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3517.507.06
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3617.707.09
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3717.607.08
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3817.607.11
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation3917.507.08
CO2 group6000 ppm incubation4017.307.05