Abstract
Environmental financing is one of the crucial issues of international environmental law and its implementation. From an environmental perspective a prerequisite for success is that financial resources are used in an environmentally effective way. Whether the World Bank, the Global Environment Facility (GEF) and the Prototype Carbon Fund (PCF) can be perceived as effective environmental actors has to be measured by their objectives, their potential to promote accepted environmental standards and their relevant funding practices. After significant improvements of their environmental policies, the World Bank must be considered the most important institution for environmental financing due to its involvement in environmental trust funds but also in regard to its regular lending practices. The GEF remains exceptional due to its institutional structure and scope, whereas the PCF is an example of public–private partnerships that might be a model for future financing via trust funds. Since acceptance of institutions can only be created if they are considered to be legitimate, legitimacy is closely tied to effectiveness. The main criteria for legitimacy are state consent and the equality of states as well as supplementary considerations such as transparency and public participation. From this perspective the World Bank, GEF and PCF structures of voting and participation have come a long way, and despite their particularities and deficiencies they reflect to a varying degree elements of legitimate decision making.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- BP:
-
Banking Policy
- CBD:
-
Convention on Biological Diversity
- CDCF:
-
Community Development Carbon Fund
- CDF:
-
Comprehensive Development Framework
- CEA:
-
Country Environmental Analysis
- EA:
-
Environmental Assessment
- GEF:
-
Global Environment Facility
- GHG:
-
greenhouse-gas
- IUCN:
-
World Conservation Union
- MEA:
-
Multilateral Environmental Agreement
- ODA:
-
Official Development Assistance
- OP:
-
Operational Policy
- PCF:
-
Prototype Carbon Fund
- POP:
-
Persistent Organic Pollutant
- SEA:
-
Strategic Environmental Analysis
- TFESSD:
-
Trust Fund for Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Development
- UN:
-
United Nations
- UNCCD:
-
United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification
- UNCED:
-
United Nations Conference on Environment and Development
- UNDP:
-
United Nations Development Programme
- UNEP:
-
United Nations Environment Programme
- UNFCCC:
-
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
- WSSD:
-
World Summit on Sustainable Development
- WTO:
-
World Trade Organisation
- WWF:
-
World Wide Fund for Nature
References
J. Alder D. Wilkinson (1999) Environmental Law and Ethics Macmillan Press Hampshire, UK
M. A. Bekhechi (1999) ArticleTitle‘Some Observations Regarding Environmental Covenants and Conditionalities in World Bank Lending Activities’ Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 3 287–314
D. Bodansky (1999) ArticleTitle‘The Legitimacy of International Governance: A Coming Challenge for International Environmental Law?’ American Journal of International Law 93 596–624
L. Boisson de Chazournes (1999a) Public Participation in Decision-making: the World Bank Inspection Panel E. Brown Weiss A. Rigo Sureda L. Boisson de Chazournes (Eds) The World Bank, International Financial Institutions, and the Development of International Law American Society of International Law Washington, DC, USA 84–94
L. Boisson de Chazournes (1999b) ArticleTitle‘The Global Environment Facility Galaxy: On Linkages among Institutions’ Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 3 243–285
Boisson de Chazournes, L. (2003), The Global Environment Facility as a Pioneering Institution – Lessons Learned and Looking Ahead, GEF Working Paper 19.
E. Brown Weiss (1999) Introductory Remarks E. Brown Weiss A. Rigo Sureda L. Boisson de Chazournes (Eds) The World Bank, International Financial Institutions, and the Development of International Law American Society of International Law Washington, D.C., USA 1–5
J. Brunnée (2002) ArticleTitle‘COPing with Consent: Law-Making Under Multilateral Environmental Agreements’ Leiden Journal of International Law 15 1–52
C. E. Leva ParticleDi (1998) ArticleTitle‘International Environmental Law and Development’ Georgetown International Law Review 10 501–549
P. Dolzer (2001) The World Bank and the Global Environment: Novel Frontiers? S. Schlemmer-Schulte K.-Y. Tung (Eds) Liber Amicorum Ibrahim F.I. Shihata – International Finance and Development Law Kluwer Law International The Netherlands 141–154
T. M. Franck (1990) The Power of Legitimacy among Nations Oxford University Press Oxford, UK
T. M. Franck (1995) Fairness in International Law and Institutions Clarendon Press Oxford, UK
T. M. Franck (2000) Legitimacy and the Democratic Entitlement G. H. Fox B. R. Roth (Eds) Democratic Governance and International Law Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK 25–47
Franz, W. E. (1996), Appendix: The Scope of Global Environmental Financing - Cases in Context, in R. O. Keohane and M. A. Levy, (eds.), Cambridge (MA) et al., USA: The MIT Press.
Freestone, D. (2001), The World Bank’s Prototype Carbon Fund: Mobilizing New Resources for Sustainable Development, in S. Schlemmer-Schulte and K.-Y. Tung, (eds.), The Hague et al., The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International.
D. Freestone (2003) ArticleTitle‘Introductory Note to the Text of the PCF Instrument’ World Bank Legal Review 1 433–524
GEF (2002), Summary of Negotiations on the Third Replenishment of the GEF Trust Fund, document accessible online at <http://www.gefweb.org/Replenishment/Joint_Summaries/joint_summaries.html>(last visited 04 November 2004).
InstitutionalAuthorNameGEF (2004) Instrument for the Establishment of the Restructured Global Environment Facility GEF Washington DC, USA
Gilbert, C. L. and D. Vines (2000), The World Bank: An Overview of some Major Issues, in C.L. Gilbert and D. Vines, (eds.), Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
J. Gupta (2003) ArticleTitle‘The Role of Non-State Actors in International Environmental Affairs’ Heidelberg Journal of International Law 63 459–486
G. Handl (2001) Multilateral Development Banking: Environmental Principles and Concepts Reflecting General International Law and Public Policy Asian Development Bank/Kluwer Law International Netherlands
D. Hunter (2003) ArticleTitle‘Using the World Bank Inspection Panel to Defend the Interests of Project-affected People’ Chicago Journal of International Law 4 201–212
IBRD (1995), Articles of Agreement (As amended effective February 16, 1989), World Bank, Washington, DC, USA.
R. O. Keohane (1996) Analysing the Effectiveness of International Environmental Institutions R. O. Keohane M. A. Levy (Eds) Institutions for Environmental Aid: Pitfalls and Promise The MIT Press Cambridge (MA) et al., USA 3–27
S. Killinger (2003) The World Bank’s Non-political Mandate Carl Heymanns Verlag Cologne et al., Germany
P. Prestre ParticleLe (1989) The World Bank and the Environmental Challenge Associated University Presses London et al., UK
Lee, C. F. (2001), International Finance Corporation: Financing Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Private Investment, in S. Schlemmer-Schulte and K.-Y. Tung, (eds.), The Hague et al., The Netherlands : Kluwer Law International.
S. Marks (2001) Democracy and International Governance J.-M. Coicaud V. Heiskanen (Eds) The Legitimacy of International Organizations United Nations University Press Tokyo et al., Japan 47–68
N. Matz (2002) ArticleTitle‘Environmental Financing: Function and Coherence of Financial Mechanisms in International Environmental Agreements’ Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 6 473–534
N. Matz (2003) ArticleTitle‘New Strategies for Environmental Financing?’ Heidelberg Journal of International Law 63 503–516
J. Pearsal (1998) The New Oxford Dictionary of English Clarendon Press Oxford, UK
Prototype Carbon Fund (2003), Annual Report 2003.
Rigo Sureda, A. (1999), The World Bank and Institutional Innovation, in E. Brown Weiss, A. Rigo Sureda and Boisson de Chazournes, (eds.), Washington, DC, USA: American Society of International Law.
S. R. Roos (2001) ArticleTitle‘The World Bank Inspection Panel in its Seventh Year: An Analysis of its Process, Mandate, and Desirability with Special Reference to the China (Tibet) Case’ Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 5 473–521
S. Schuppert (2000) Economic Incentives as Control Measures F. Morrison R. Wolfrum (Eds) International, Regional and National Environmental Law Kluwer Law International The Hague et al., The Netherlands 861–886
I. Shihata (1994) The World Bank Inspection Panel Oxford University Press Oxford et al., UK
I. Shihata (1995) The World Bank in a Changing World, Vol. II Martinus Nijhoff Publishers The Hague et al., The Netherlands
I. Shihata (1998) The World Bank’s Contribution to the Development of International Environmental Law G. Hafner (Eds) Liber Amicorum Professor Ignaz Seidl-Hohenveldern in Honour of his 80th Birthday Kluwer Law International The Hague et al., Netherlands 631–657
H. Sjöberg (1996) The Global Environment Facility J. Werksman (Eds) Greening International Institutions Earthscan Publications London, UK 148–162
Sjöberg, H. (1999), Restructuring the Global Environment Facility, GEF Working Paper 13.
A. Slaughter (2000) ArticleTitle‘Building Global Democracy’ Chicago Journal of International Law 1 223–229
J. R. Walsh (2004) ArticleTitle‘Major Infrastructure Projects, Biodiversity and the Precautionary Principle: The Case of the Yacyretá Dam and Iberá Marshes’ Review of European Community and International Law 13 61–71
J. Werksman (1993) Greening Bretton Woods P. Sands (Eds) Greening International Law Earthscan Publications London, UK 65–84
J. Werksman (1995) ArticleTitle‘Consolidating Governance of the Global Commons: Insights from the GEF’ Yearbook of International Environmental Law 6 27–63
R. Wolfrum (1998) ArticleTitle‘Means of Ensuring Compliance with and Enforcement of International Environmental Law’ Recueil de Cours 272 7–154
World Bank (2000), Donor Survey of Environmental Aid Effectiveness, prepared by H.O. Ibrekk, Report no. 26669.
InstitutionalAuthorNameWorld Bank (2001) Making Sustainable Commitments: An Environment Strategy for the World Bank World Bank Publisher Washington, DC, USA
InstitutionalAuthorNameWorld Bank (2003) The World Bank Annual Report NumberInSeriesVol. 1 World Bank Publisher Washington, DC, USA
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Matz, N. Financial Institutions between Effectiveness and Legitimacy – A Legal Analysis of the World Bank, Global Environment Facility and Prototype Carbon Fund. Int Environ Agreements 5, 265–302 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10784-005-3806-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10784-005-3806-7