Citation:

j.jembe.2010.11.009

Name: Seawater carbonate chemistry and biological processes of Porites panamensis during experiments, 2011
Published: 2011-06-16
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
Keywords: Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Cnidaria; Coast and continental shelf; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Laboratory experiment; Mortality/Survival; North Pacific; Porites panamensis; Reproduction; Single species; Temperature; Tropical

Always quote citation above when using data! You can download the citation in several formats below.

RIS Citation BibTeX Citation Text Citation Facebook Twitter

Abstract:

Survival of coral planulae, and the successful settlement and healthy growth of primary polyps are critical for the dispersal of scleractinian corals and hence the recovery of degraded coral reefs. It is therefore important to explore how the warmer and more acidic oceanic conditions predicted for the future could affect these processes. This study used controlled culture to investigate the effects of a 1 °C increase in temperature and a 0.2-0.25 unit decrease in pH on the settlement and survival of planulae and the growth of primary polyps in the Tropical Eastern Pacific coral Porites panamensis. We found that primary polyp growth was reduced only marginally by more acidic seawater but the combined effect of high temperature and lowered pH caused a significant reduction in growth of primary polyps by almost a third. Elevated temperature was found to significantly reduce the amount of zooxanthellae in primary polyps, and when combined with lowered pH resulted in a significant reduction in biomass of primary polyps. However, survival and settlement of planula larvae were unaffected by increased temperature, lowered acidity or the combination of both. These results indicate that in future scenarios of increased temperature and oceanic acidity coral planulae will be able to disperse and settle successfully but primary polyp growth may be hampered. The recovery of reefs may therefore be impeded by global change even if local stressors are curbed and sufficient sources of planulae are available.

Keyword(s):

Animalia; Benthic animals; Benthos; Cnidaria; Coast and continental shelf; Containers and aquaria (20-1000 L or < 1 m**2); Laboratory experiment; Mortality/Survival; North Pacific; Porites panamensis; Reproduction; Single species; Temperature; Tropical

Project(s):

European network of excellence for Ocean Ecosystems Analysis (EUR-OCEANS)

European Project on Ocean Acidification (EPOCA)

Ocean Acidification International Coordination Centre (OA-ICC)

Funding:

Seventh Framework Programme (FP7), grant/award no. 211384 : European Project on Ocean Acidification

Sixth Framework Programme (FP6), grant/award no. 511106 : European network of excellence for Ocean Ecosystems Analysis

Comment:

In order to allow full comparability with other ocean acidification data sets, the R package seacarb (Lavigne and Gattuso, 2011) was used to compute a complete and consistent set of carbonate system variables, as described by Nisumaa et al. (2010). In this dataset the original values were archived in addition with the recalculated parameters (see related PI).

Parameter(s):

#	Name	Short Name	Unit	Principal Investigator	Method/Device	Comment
1	Identification	ID		Anlauf, Holger
2	Experimental treatment	Exp treat		Anlauf, Holger
3	Salinity	Sal		Anlauf, Holger
4	Temperature, water	Temp	°C	Anlauf, Holger		Mean
5	Temperature, water	Temp	°C	Anlauf, Holger		Maximum
6	Temperature, water	Temp	°C	Anlauf, Holger		Minimum
7	pH	pH		Anlauf, Holger		NBS scale, mean
8	pH	pH		Anlauf, Holger		NBS scale, maximum
9	pH	pH		Anlauf, Holger		NBS scale, minimum
10	Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	pCO2water_SST_wet	µatm	Anlauf, Holger
11	Aragonite saturation state	Omega Arg		Anlauf, Holger	Calculated using CO2SYS
12	Alkalinity, total	AT	µmol/kg	Anlauf, Holger	Titration
13	Zooxanthellae per polyp	Zoox/polyp	#	Anlauf, Holger
14	Porites panamensis, settled	P. panamensis sett	%	Anlauf, Holger
15	Porites panamensis, motile	P. panamensis motile	%	Anlauf, Holger
16	Porites panamensis, dead	P. panamensis d	%	Anlauf, Holger
17	Porites panamensis, mortality, post settlement	P. panamensis psm	%	Anlauf, Holger
18	Carbonate system computation flag	CSC flag		Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
19	pH	pH		Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)	Total scale
20	Carbon dioxide	CO2	µmol/kg	Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
21	Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	pCO2water_SST_wet	µatm	Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
22	Fugacity of carbon dioxide (water) at sea surface temperature (wet air)	fCO2water_SST_wet	µatm	Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
23	Bicarbonate ion	[HCO3]-	µmol/kg	Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
24	Carbonate ion	[CO3]2-	µmol/kg	Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
25	Carbon, inorganic, dissolved	DIC	µmol/kg	Anlauf, Holger	Calculated using CO2SYS
26	Alkalinity, total	AT	µmol/kg	Anlauf, Holger	Calculated using CO2SYS
27	Aragonite saturation state	Omega Arg		Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)
28	Calcite saturation state	Omega Cal		Nisumaa, Anne-Marin	Calculated using seacarb after Nisumaa et al. (2010)

License:

Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported (CC-BY-3.0)

Status:

Curation Level: Enhanced curation (CurationLevelC)

Size:

1881 data points

Data

Download dataset as tab-delimited text — use the following character encoding:

1 ID	2 Exp treat	3 Sal	4 Temp [°C] (Mean)	5 Temp [°C] (Maximum)	6 Temp [°C] (Minimum)	7 pH (NBS scale, mean)	8 pH (NBS scale, maximum)	9 pH (NBS scale, minimum)	10 pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm]	11 Omega Arg (Calculated using CO2SYS)	12 AT [µmol/kg] (Titration)	13 Zoox/polyp [#]	14 P. panamensis sett [%]	15 P. panamensis motile [%]	16 P. panamensis d [%]	17 P. panamensis psm [%]	18 CSC flag (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	19 pH (Total scale, Calculated using...)	20 CO2 [µmol/kg] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	21 pCO2water_SST_wet [µatm] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	22 fCO2water_SST_wet [µatm] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	23 [HCO3]- [µmol/kg] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	24 [CO3]2- [µmol/kg] (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	25 DIC [µmol/kg] (Calculated using CO2SYS)	26 AT [µmol/kg] (Calculated using CO2SYS)	27 Omega Arg (Calculated using seacarb afte...)	28 Omega Cal (Calculated using seacarb afte...)
Settle experiment	Ambient	27.84	28.31	29.22	27.30	8.08	8.19	8.03	487.09	2.17	1798.1		52	3	38	7	29	7.93	13.19	487.35	485.88	1579.45	137.16	1729.8	1917.3	2.30	3.53
Settle experiment	Ambient	27.84	28.31	29.22	27.30	8.08	8.19	8.03	487.09	2.17	1798.1		30	0	53	17	29	7.93	13.19	487.35	485.88	1579.45	137.16	1729.8	1917.3	2.30	3.53
Settle experiment	Ambient	27.84	28.31	29.22	27.30	8.08	8.19	8.03	487.09	2.17	1798.1		37	6	57	0	29	7.93	13.19	487.35	485.88	1579.45	137.16	1729.8	1917.3	2.30	3.53
Settle experiment	Ambient	27.84	28.31	29.22	27.30	8.08	8.19	8.03	487.09	2.17	1798.1		52	0	48	0	29	7.93	13.19	487.35	485.88	1579.45	137.16	1729.8	1917.3	2.30	3.53
Settle experiment	Ambient	27.84	28.31	29.22	27.30	8.08	8.19	8.03	487.09	2.17	1798.1		63	3	33	0	29	7.93	13.19	487.35	485.88	1579.45	137.16	1729.8	1917.3	2.30	3.53
Settle experiment	Low pH	27.84	28.37	29.20	27.30	7.85	7.92	7.77	861.91	1.36	1763.5		33	0	57	10	29	7.70	23.29	861.91	859.30	1644.70	84.31	1752.3	1853.4	1.41	2.17
Settle experiment	Low pH	27.84	28.37	29.20	27.30	7.85	7.92	7.77	861.91	1.36	1763.5		47	0	50	3	29	7.70	23.29	861.91	859.30	1644.70	84.31	1752.3	1853.4	1.41	2.17
Settle experiment	Low pH	27.84	28.37	29.20	27.30	7.85	7.92	7.77	861.91	1.36	1763.5		17	33	50	0	29	7.70	23.29	861.91	859.30	1644.70	84.31	1752.3	1853.4	1.41	2.17
Settle experiment	Low pH	27.84	28.37	29.20	27.30	7.85	7.92	7.77	861.91	1.36	1763.5		47	0	53	0	29	7.70	23.29	861.91	859.30	1644.70	84.31	1752.3	1853.4	1.41	2.17
Settle experiment	Low pH	27.84	28.37	29.20	27.30	7.85	7.92	7.77	861.91	1.36	1763.5		20	0	70	10	29	7.70	23.29	861.91	859.30	1644.70	84.31	1752.3	1853.4	1.41	2.17
Settle experiment	High T	27.84	29.56	29.22	27.30	8.07	8.17	8.02	493.69	2.14	1762.2		27	0	63	10	29	7.92	12.99	494.47	493.00	1544.33	136.18	1693.5	1880.8	2.30	3.52
Settle experiment	High T	27.84	29.56	29.22	27.30	8.07	8.17	8.02	493.69	2.14	1762.2		10	0	87	3	29	7.92	12.99	494.47	493.00	1544.33	136.18	1693.5	1880.8	2.30	3.52
Settle experiment	High T	27.84	29.56	29.22	27.30	8.07	8.17	8.02	493.69	2.14	1762.2		37	7	47	10	29	7.92	12.99	494.47	493.00	1544.33	136.18	1693.5	1880.8	2.30	3.52
Settle experiment	High T	27.84	29.56	29.22	27.30	8.07	8.17	8.02	493.69	2.14	1762.2		9	0	91	0	29	7.92	12.99	494.47	493.00	1544.33	136.18	1693.5	1880.8	2.30	3.52
Settle experiment	High T	27.84	29.56	29.22	27.30	8.07	8.17	8.02	493.69	2.14	1762.2		70	10	20	0	29	7.92	12.99	494.47	493.00	1544.33	136.18	1693.5	1880.8	2.30	3.52
Settle experiment	Low pH + High T	27.84	29.47	29.22	1.89	7.83	7.91	7.77	950.72	1.35	1801.2		37	3	50	10	29	7.68	25.06	951.88	949.04	1712.93	86.70	1824.7	1925.8	1.47	2.24
Settle experiment	Low pH + High T	27.84	29.47	29.22	1.89	7.83	7.91	7.77	950.72	1.35	1801.2		79	0	10	10	29	7.68	25.06	951.88	949.04	1712.93	86.70	1824.7	1925.8	1.47	2.24
Settle experiment	Low pH + High T	27.84	29.47	29.22	1.89	7.83	7.91	7.77	950.72	1.35	1801.2		47	23	30	0	29	7.68	25.06	951.88	949.04	1712.93	86.70	1824.7	1925.8	1.47	2.24
Settle experiment	Low pH + High T	27.84	29.47	29.22	1.89	7.83	7.91	7.77	950.72	1.35	1801.2		21	0	66	14	29	7.68	25.06	951.88	949.04	1712.93	86.70	1824.7	1925.8	1.47	2.24
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	2622					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	5978					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	958					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	4544					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	7519					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	7750					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	3367					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	817					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	569					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	2311					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	2142					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	4958					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	4225					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	2639					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Ambient	28.20	28.84	30.60	27.30	8.03	8.19	7.87	546.24	2.01	1792.1	3347					29	7.88	14.59	546.80	545.16	1574.77	125.14	1714.5	1884.4	2.10	3.21
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	8689					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	7546					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	4433					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	1678					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	2100					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	2922					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	6533					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	1097					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	4639					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	836					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	1514					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	633					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	6000					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	3593					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	3167					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	4176					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	3317					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	817					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	Low pH	28.10	28.97	30.64	27.30	7.83	7.93	7.68	926.94	1.35	1791.1	759					29	7.68	24.68	927.71	924.92	1682.43	84.48	1791.6	1890.9	1.42	2.17
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	1292					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	2458					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	1389					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	917					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	1319					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	403					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	875					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	2694					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	2306					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	High T	27.90	29.88	30.60	27.30	8.04	8.17	7.87	540.68	2.06	1773.9	1481					29	7.89	14.11	541.32	539.72	1573.90	131.09	1719.1	1897.2	2.22	3.39
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	1400					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	5652					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	6000					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	3333					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	3278					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	1039					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	1644					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	1614					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	1514					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	917					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	5056					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	4222					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20
Growth experiment	Low pH + High T	28.10	29.86	30.60	27.30	7.81	7.91	7.64	1006.32	1.34	1826.8	1097					29	7.66	26.24	1007.13	1004.14	1728.23	85.22	1839.7	1937.4	1.44	2.20